Latviski English По-русски
Saturday 18.11.2017 | Name days: Doloresa, Aleksandrs

Latvian courts: How incorruptible and independent?

(No Ratings Yet)

Although the Latvian court system is still relatively “young”, its participants – judges and prosecutors – have already managed to violate laws and ethical principles. They have got involved in numerous corruption scandals.

Judges being tried

Recently the Latvian court system has come into spotlight for various reasons, but most importantly due to the detention of Ziedonis Strazds, judge at Zemgale Suburb Court. He was detained on August 5, 2012, for money-driven abuse of office, employment of nonexistent persons and money withdrawal from their bank accounts.

Riga Regional Court judge Skaidrite Buivide was named as a suspect. She was allegedly backing the scheme of employing fake staff. Both of the judges were imposed non-custodial security measures. But they both fell ill shortly after being interrogated by the Corruption Prevention and Combating Bureau.

It should be added that on August 20 Justice Minister, Janis Bordans, launched disciplinary action against Strazds. The respective document was sent to the Court Administration. However, when the paper reached the Judicial Disciplinary Committee, its Chairman chose to send it back to the Justice Minister. The Chair was seeking to prevent deficiencies and meet the requirements laid down in the Law on Disciplinary Liability, Article 3, Part 2 and 3. Bordans said he did not see why the Judicial Disciplinary Committee had opted for such a move. He raised concern that it was a bid to delay the proceedings. Nevertheless, Bordans stressed that the disciplinary proceedings would not be withdrawn.

Under the Latvian law, judges’ reputation must be impeccable. But in practice they are allowed to go on working even when they are suspected of having committed some criminal offense. They can do it as long as the Saeima (Parliament) does not dismiss them.

Although criminal proceedings have been launched against Strazds, he was not banned from working as a judge. He and Buivide chose not to keep working. But they did not do it out of respect for courts and labour laws. They were actually being very sly. Just like many other suspects, they fell ill and were “forced” to go on a sick leave. Besides, the law provides that a judge cannot be dismissed without his explanation that shall be assessed also after criminal proceedings have been launched. This means that Strazds would be merely forbidden to keep serving as the Chairman of Riga City Zemgale Suburb Court.

This is not a unique case. Judges have already previously managed to get involved into all kinds of scandals and tarnish the reputation of their fair colleagues.

Back on June 1, 2006, the corruption watchdog detained judge Valda Strode, head of Daugavpils Land Register Office. The Supreme Court sentenced her to imprisonment for two years with confiscation of property. Aina Freimane, judge of Jurmala Land Register Office, has also been caught abusing office. She was imposed half-a-year-long suspended sentence and a fine.

Similarly, back in September, 2008, Diana Masina from Riga City Latgale District Court was also accused of intentionally coming up with an unlawful ruling. She was imposed a two-year- and-six-month long suspended sentence with a probationary period of two years. She was also applied a fine of 3 200 lats ($ 5 926) for abuse of office.

History of Latvian courts also features cases with incomprehensible income of judges. In fact, back in 2006 ex-judge of Riga District Court, Valdemars Subrovskis, became a millionaire. He sold a land plot in the Latvian city of Sigulda for 970 000 lats ($1.79m).

Also, when he chose to step down, his income statement showed he had managed to shed 417 000 lats (772 222) in less than a year’s time. It should be added that the scandalous book Legal Proceedings as a Kitchen (Latvian: Tiesasanas ka Kekis) features a character, allegedly inspired by the judge.

Of all the notorious cases, the one with Vidzeme District Court Chair Irena Polikarpova and judge Beatrise Talere stands out the most. The first instance court jailed both of the ladies for eight years, but they appealed to the Supreme Court. This was the very first time when criminal proceedings were launched against judges, who had not stepped down or been dismissed.

The appeal was supposed to be heard on October, 2010. Although the first instance court did not arrest the judges, they were banned from leaving the country and approaching specific people as well as places. In July 2010, Talere died after a protracted illness, but Polikarpova was imposed three-year imprisonment and partial seizure of her property.

Similarly, on June, 2012, the Judicial Disciplinary Committee called on the Parliament to dismiss Daugavpils judge Ernests Joksts. He was said to have intentionally violated the law when ruling on some criminal case. Having held a hearing on November, 2011, the judge said a complete ruling would be read on November 24. But without a good reason, he failed to comply with the deadline and did not even declare that no ruling could be expected. Thus, he breached Criminal Law Article 530 Part 2 and 3, as well as Article 49, Paragraph 1. Taking into account that disciplinary action had already been brought against him twice, the Judicial Disciplinary Committee opted for asking the Parliament to dismiss him.

Continuing to enumerate various scandals around judges, one must not miss out on Juris Freimanis, whose activities suggest close friendship with Ventspils politicians.

BNN already reported, Freimanis is no stranger to the Ventspils political elite. Back in 2002, Laimonis Strujevics, the former Economy Minister and the current head of Ventspils municipal Economy Department, submitted a claim against journalist Aivars Ozolins about disrespect to the dignity. Back then, when ruling in favour of his Ventspils fellow, Freimanis felt as an expert in the field of psychological conscience.

He said the ruling was based on generally accepted psychological knowledge that people are vulnerable. The ruling left us all pondering whether journalists must watch out not to hurt anyone too much.

The judge’s current day-to-day, however, features rulings in relation to the rights of Ventbunkers shareholders. Decisions always seem to satisfy the needs of Aivars Lembergs’ follower – Olafs Berkis.

“Freimanis’ September 18 ruling is outrageous. It is legally controversial and clearly shows that the judge has not even tried to understand the claim, merely accepting what his loyal clients say,” says Aivars Gobins, representative of AS Ventbunkers.

According to him, judge Freimanis dares openly serving Ventspils money bags – Berkis and Olegs Stepanovs. He does what their lawyers say, just like when he was receiving calls from lawyer “Gutups” (a character in Legal Proceedings as a Kitchen, allegedly inspired by lawyer Andris Grutups).

Indeed, Freimanis’ repuation is far from an impeccable one. Journalist Lato Lapsa’s book Legal Proceedings as a Kitchen also features some Juris Frimanis, a character allegedly inspired by Freimanis. The book revealed unlawfully tapped phone conversations between Grutups (a close person to the People’s Party) and Latvian court staff, as well as those in charge of home affairs.

In Legal Proceedings as a Kitchen, “Gutups” offers “Frimanis” a copy of his book on the Latvian property reform. The judge says he would like to have one, but the lawyer then insists that it is better to copy the best pages.

Prosecutors being tried

It is not that judges are the only slaves of money. Also prosecutors do not mind cashing in.

Back on October 20, 2008, the Corruption Prevention and Combatting Bureau detained Jurmala prosecutor Irina Bogdanova. She was caught accepting a bribe of 15 000 lats ($ 27 777), but the total amount was supposed to reach 25 000 lats ($ 46 290). She was allegedly demanding the money in return for a favorable ruling.

On April 26, 2004, the anti-corruption office detained Juris Ziemelis, prosecutor at the Riga Jurisdiction Prosecutor’s Office. He was caught accepting a bribe of 10 000 dollars (LVL 5 530). The man was suspected of demanding the bribe in return for withdrawal of criminal appeal.

The particular case shocked the system, with then-Attorney General Janis Maizitis saying that he was already tired of unfair prosecutors.

Law enforcement authorities have also detained two prosecutors from the Specialized Prosecutor’s Office of Organized Crime and other branches. Stanislavs Nazarovs and Aigars Cusko were detained back in 2003.

In June 2002, the criminal police detained Arturs Krievs, a prosecutor at the Vidzeme District Prosecutor’s Office. He was caught offering a bribe to some Valmiera prosecutor, so that she would dismiss certain criminal proceedings.

Also Kurzeme district court prosecutor, Vladimirs Cerikovs, has been detained for accepting a bribe of 2 000 lats ($ 3 703). Back in 2001, Daugavpils prosecutor Aleksejs Margevics was caught accepting a bribe of 5 000 lats ($ 9 259).

All these are just a couple of countless other examples showing that frequently court decisions are being taken at a dinner table among friendly judges, prosecutors and advocates.

While the Latvian court system remains surrounded by numerous scandals, they cast shadows over any confidence that it is the right place to seek the truth.

Ref: 102/

Leave a reply

NAF: Russia’s attitude remains unfriendly towards Latvia

So far Russia’s demonstrated attitude has remained unfriendly towards Latvia, said Commander of Latvian Armed Forces Leonīds Kalniņš in an interview to LNT.

Lembergs’ turn to testify before parliamentary committee has come

Aivars Lembergs, who is accused of serious crimes and is suspended from performing duties as chairman of Ventspils City Council, has been invited to come to a meeting of the Saeima’s Investigative Committee and answer questions associated with so-called oligarchs case.

How Latvian communities around the world plan to celebrate Latvia’s birthday?

«Celebration of independence of the Republic of Latvia is an important tradition that allows members of Latvia’s diaspora to maintain ties with their homeland – this year’s event will be even more expansive and inclusive than ever before. This is because events associated with the country’s hundredth birthday will be organized all around the world,» says manager of World Federation of Free Latvians office in Latvia Jānis Andersons.

European Parliament triggers punitive procedure against Poland

Members of the European Parliament have passed a resolution requesting for the application of the so-called «nuclear option» for Poland, Article 7 of the EU Treaty, because of the threat to the rule of law in the biggest Eastern European country.

Wage rules violations most often associated with envelope wages

To promote public awareness and improve commercial environment, honest competition and honest compliance with taxes, Latvia’s State Revenue Service intends to expand its database with new information about taxpayers, BNN was told by SRS.

Management of Unity’s Saeima faction to change in December

«Political consultations with all of Unity’s partner parties that are represented in the Saeima’s faction have concluded. An agreement has been reached to perform management change before the end of Saeima’s autumn session – around 21 December,» says Unity’s chairman Arvils Ašeradens.

EP prepared to commence talks with EU governments on reforming asylum system

The European Parliament is prepared to commence talks about reforming Dublin Regulation to ensure every member state is able to resettle a portion of asylum seekers.

Estonia to pour into Finnish-Estonian cultural fund 700 000 euros

Estonian cabinet of ministers has decided to attribute 700,000 euros to the Finno-Estonian Cultural Fund, an organisation working since 2015 aimed at fostering cooperation between the two states in culture, creative economy and training both for individuals and organizations.

Russia in UN vetoes extension of Syrian chemical attack investigation

At the UN Security Council, Russia has used its veto powers to block a resolution with which it would be allowed to continue the international investigation into a chemical attack this spring in Syria, which prompted the U.S. to launch missile strikes on a Syrian airbase.

Latvia’s birthday expected to be windy

A precipitation zone will reach Latvia from the west on Friday, 17 November. The precipitation zone will, however, pass over Latvia quickly, making rainfall short and periods of clear sky more frequent and longer. Air temperature is expected to stay within +5° C… +8° C, as reported by State Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

State of emergency in force in flood-hit Greece

Rescue services in Greece are looking for no less than five people, who have gone missing following unexpected and disastrous floods on Wednesday, November 15, that killed 15 people; however, bad weather is still expected.

Laupīšanas 101 director: Latvia’s film industry has yet to reach its potential height

There is sufficient evidence to prove that Latvia’s film industry is capable, but at the same time many films are directed basically the same way. There is a lack of creativity, which means very slow development for the industry, said Kaspars Marhlevičs, director of short comedy Laupīšanas 101, in an interview to BNN.

Medical cannabis bill paves way in Lithuanian legislature

Otherwise conservative Lithuania has made a big stride forward legalising cannabis for medical use with 92 Lithuanian parliamentarians voting Thursday, November 15, to open the bill draft on medication containing cannabis. The law draft should go back to the parliamentary floor for deliberations on December 12.

Latvian sentenced to ten years in prison for fighting on the side of ISIS in Syria

On Thursday, 16 November, Latvian citizen Mārtiņš Grīnbergs was sentenced by Riga Regional Court to ten years and three months in prison for fighting on the side of Islamic State terrorist organization.

European Parliament: Africa’s development requires a new stimulus

To resolve economic, social and migration-related problems, which usually accompany lasting crises, better African-EU cooperation is needed, European Parliament members say.

Latvian Chamber for Commerce and Industry proposes preventing new MPC reforms

Increase of mandatory procurement components cannot be allowed. Exactly the opposite – this cost should be dropped entirely for end electricity prices in an attempt to improve international competitiveness of companies, BNN was told by council members of Latvian Chamber for Commerce and Industry.

Matīss: LDz cannot raise tariffs and perform rail electrification under cargo anti-record

Because Latvijas dzelzceļš has set an anti-record in cargo transports in the first ten months of this year, Saeima deputy and member of the National Economy Committee Anrijs Matīss says raising the fee for the use of infrastructure cannot be allowed. He adds that the intended railway electrification project should be considered very carefully.

Lithuania and Latvia placed in top 10 in climate policy index

In the annual Climate Change Performance Index, where climate policy action in 57 countries has been evaluated, on a scale from «very high» to «very low», 11 EU member states have been evaluated with as having been highly active, with Sweden showing the best results ahead of Lithuania, the UK, Finland and Latvia.

Bite Latvija buys Stream Networks and Latnet

Mobile commutations operator Bite Latvija has signed a purchase agreement for 100% of shares of Stream Networks and its subsidiary Latner Serviss, as BNN was informed by Bite manager in Latvia Kaspars Buls.

airBaltic carried three million passengers in first ten months of 2017

In the first ten months of 2017, airBaltic carried a total of 3,007,034 passengers to destinations in Europe, Scandinavia, Russia, CIS and the Middle East, BNN was told by the company.

Kaljulaid sees African opportunities to outplace EU in digitalisation

During a visit to Ethiopia, Estonian President Kersti Kaljulaid has discussed African-EU relations with the African Commissioner for Trade and Industry and recommended investing into digital development that would be beneficial for the continent itself.

Most employed people in Latvia are satisfied with their jobs

More and more often employers experience lack of qualified labour force, as well as increase of employees’ confidence about their competitiveness on the labour market and their openness for better job offers.

Estonian railways operator happy about increasing freight volume

Freight carried on the infrastructure of the Estonian state railway company Estonian Railways in October amounted to one million tons, which is a 10.4% hike compared to October 2016.

European Parliament: rule of law in Malta should be monitored more closely

Malta should strengthen the rule of law and the European Commission should follow the situation in the country more closely to ensure objective protection of rights, members of the European Parliament say.

Greece hit by sudden, disastrous floods

Towns in central Greece have suffered severe damages as unexpectedly heavy rain caused floods on Wednesday, November 15, taking the lives of no less than 15 people.