Latviski English По-русски
Tuesday 26.09.2017 | Name days: Kurts, Knuts, Gundars

Lawyer: if LMT and Lattelecom are merged, Latvia will lose the most

(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RUContradictory opinions about the merge between Latvijas Mobilais Telefons and Lattelecom have become especially loud in recent weeks. If the merge is carried out, Latvia will lose the most, says partner of Vilgerts law firm Julija Jerneva.

She believes the merge of LMT and Lattelecom is less than beneficial for the state as a shareholder. «By allowing the merge, the country would lose control, whereas Telia Sonera Group would gain controlling package of shares. This would also mean a considerable reduction of the value of shares owned by the state,» says Jerneva.

Swedes’ desire for control through merge is clear as day

«It is clear that this scenario would benefit the Swedish side, which explains the recent clash between LMT council representatives,» the expert says.

At the same time, she says that LMT Council chairman and representative of Telia Company AB Claes Nykander had reacted sharply to LMT President Juris Binde’s criticism of the idea to merge LMT and Lattelecom, saying that it is unacceptable, does not represent the opinion of the majority of council members and «questions the management’s ability to honestly represent interests of all LMT owners and manage the company in the future». Meanwhile, another LMT Council member – Anri Leimanis – has said that Nykander’s announcement came as a surprise, because the council has never decided on such a matter.

«Looking from the sidelines, such public laundry-tossing and threats coming from Telia Sonera Group to punish those who criticize the idea to merge LMT and Lattelecom one gets the impression of a hint of nervousness coming from Sweden. It seems Telia Sonera Group’s interest includes merging the two companies no matter the cost and increasing its already enormous influence,» the expert comments.

At first glance, KPMG’s proposal to form a company after merging LMT and Lattelecom in which 30-40% of shares are provided to the biggest shareholders – Telia Sonera and Latvian state – and the rest are released on the exchange would resolve the problem of Swedish dominance. Unfortunately, a closer look reveals a lot more, says the expert.

She adds: «It is not about massive investments of time and money needed to realize the merge in accordance with KPMG’s proposal. Only after carefully evaluating both companies does it become clear how much of the newly formed company would belong to Telia Sonera Group and how much – to the Latvian state.»

The expert continues: «If the evaluation shows that LMT is more valuable than Lattelecom, Telia Sonera Group will get a controlling package of shares in the new company. For Telia Sonera Group to refuse the controlling package and sell shares for unpredictable prices would be illogical. This is why to realize KPMG’s proposal for equal division of shares and make sure Swedes voluntarily sign the new agreement Latvia would have to pay a considerable compensation. Nothing is mentioned about this in public. The same applies to the question as to who will cover Telia Sonera Group’s losses from merging the two companies (because the Swedish side will definitely demand that).»

Competition and residents will be on the losing side as well

Those in support of the idea of LMT and Lattelecom merging enthusiastically claim that there is no other way and the two companies have to merge. Otherwise, they say, other market players may form an integrated operator that would take away part of the market from LMT ant Lattelecom and that Latvia would suffer considerable losses as a result, says the expert.

From a competition standpoint, such concerns are completely flat and unjustified. There is not a single company in Latvia with such a large share in internet, television, mobile and fixed communications to match LMT and Lattelecom together. This means that should LMT and Lattelecom join forces, a new player would be created with a number of considerable advantages.

«Such a massive economic power dominating the market would definitely weaken competitors and force retail prices to rise. LMT and Lattelecom competitors likely will not be able to form a sizeable offer to match them in the near future. Because of that, it is naïve to think such a massive company will not be tempted to abuse its power at the expense of clients and consumers,» the expert continues.

The expert also mentions that «even now it can be said that following this road would result in Latvian consumers being forced to hope for a new telecommunication giant entering the country in the future to balance the market and putting an end to the dominance of the merged company.»

Looking at publicly available information about the merge between LMT and Lattelecom, only one question appears: «Who would benefit from it?» It is clear this merge is not beneficial to market participants, Latvia or residents, the expert notes.

Independent experts say it is necessary to merge LMT and Lattelecom

It is worth mentioning that Telia Company values Latvian government’s decision to publish KPMG’s assessment of the government’s strategy in relation to ownership rights in LMT and Lattelecom. «We believe that transparent and open debates are the way to go to resolve this matter. We anxiously wait for the auditor’s report,» company representatives say.

«As far as we are aware, KPMG has detailed in the report that the current ownership structure is sub-optimal and that merging of the two companies is supported – it is an approach Telia Company has been proposing for a long time as the only solution to secure sustainable future for LMT and Lattelecom,» experts say.

At the same time, Telia Company’s representatives notes that the company is prepared to become involved in a constructive and open dialogue with all sides. The company hopes for a soon conclusion of internal discussions.


Leave a reply

Poland’s Duda to-and-fro with another justice reform

The President of Poland Andrzej Duda has announced and on the same day withdrawn proposals that would give the President a final say in appointing judges, after it became clear that there would be no parliamentary majority in parliament for the move.

airBaltic ticket prices expected to decline next year

Prices of tickets for flights of Latvian national airBaltic airline may decline somewhat next year, says airBaltic CEO Martin Gauss.

Merkel wishes to regain voters lost to anti-Islam party

German Chancellor Angela Merkel, after her Christian democrats won the Bundestag election with their worst result in 70 years, has expressed a wish to regain the support of voters lost to the anti-Islam right-wing party Alternative für Deutschland.

Does Lembergs lie in court when he denies participation in multiple foreign businesses?

On Monday, 25 September, infamous Ventspils resident Aivars Lembergs, who stands accused of serious crimes, denied his participation in multiple foreign businesses.

WM: the plan to increase family benefits requires additional EUR 12 million

Because of funding deficit, Welfare Ministry offers correcting the size of state benefits for first, second and every following child in a family, Diena wrote with reference to Welfare Minister Jāņis Reirs.

UN: Russia committing grave human rights violations in occupied Crimea

According to a UN human rights reports, Russian authorities in the occupied Crimea have performed serious violations of human rights with forcing its citizenship and prisoner deportation allegedly being among them.

Ministry: Latvia has resettled 65% of the planned number of refugees

In the two years provided for the completion of the established asylum seeker resettlement project, Latvia has resettled 346 out of 531 asylum seekers, explains Interior Affairs Ministry. This means Latvia will not face sanctions for non-compliance with commitments.

70 electric car recharge stations to be built in Latvia

70 electric car recharge stations are planned to be built in Latvia before the middle of 2018, as reported by Road Traffic Safety Directorate representative Rolands Rumba.

Wild animals to be kept away from Rail Baltica by warning sounds, less fences

A study is conducted in Estonia with researchers suggesting that part of the fences planned for the upcoming Rail Baltica railway could be substituted with sonic animal repellers.

Sprūds: Germany can expect very hard compromises coming after elections

Germany can expect heavy compromises after the recent elections, said director of Latvia’s Foreign Policy Institute Andris Sprūds in an interview to 900 seconds programme of LNT.

Making of biomethane fuel to be supported in Estonia

In Estonia, applying for state subsidies for the production of biomethane will open from 2018 and the Baltic country seeks to increase the consumption of the domestically produced and more environmentally friendly fuel.

Rinkēvičs: UN Security Council’s work on preventing mass crimes is ineffective

«Unfortunately, the veto right privilege of countries represented in the UN Security Council is often abused, which results in paralysis of the council’s work,» says Latvian Foreign Affairs Minister Edgars Rinkēvičs.

Statue to Kalashnikov features Nazi gun

From the monument to Russian arms inventor Mikhail Kalashnikov, unveiled in Moscow last week, an image of a German firearm has been cut after it has been depicted by mistake as a variation of the AK-47 gun.

Exporters look at air freight opportunities at Riga airport

Last week, representatives of more than 40 Latvian exporting companies gathered at Riga International Airport to look at air freight opportunities offered by the airport and companies working there.

KNAB launched seven separate corruption cases in healthcare in last three years

Corruption Prevention and Combating Bureau submitted to the prosecutor’s office a total of seven criminal processes regarding corruption in Latvia’s healthcare system in the last three years.

German election ends with record-low win for Merkel’s Christian democrats

Federal parliamentary election has been held in Germany and Christian democrats, led by long-time Chancellor Angela Merkel have won, but anti-immigration Alternative für Deutschland have gained their first seats in the federal parliament.

Weather in Latvia to gradually start getting colder in Latvia

Similar to last weekend, weather in Latvia will be dictated by a high atmospheric pressure area with a centre above Scandinavia’s eastern parts. This means the sky will be clear, no precipitation will come, and wind speed will be moderate, as reported by State Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

BNN summary of the week: Vējoņis’ authority under fire and Loginovs ordered to repay illegal donations

BNN offers a summary of this week’s topical news in a variety of categories: Fight; Truth; Business; Future; Growth and Opinion.

Kariņš: Unity started drifting when Valdis Dombrovskis left is management

Unity should seriously consider the option of starting in Saeima elections alongside other parties, said MEP Krišjānis Kariņš in an interview to Latvijas Radio.

CSP: average size of agricultural areas increases in Latvia

In 2016 the average size of agricultural holding constituted 43.2 ha, which is 15.5 % more than in 2013 when the average land area per holding accounted for 37.4 ha. The total standard output has risen by 24.5 %. Nevertheless, the number of economically active farms has reduced by 14.5 %.

Antāne forms a new political party in Ventspils with more than 350 associates

A new political party was founded in Ventspils this Thursday, 21 September. The name of this new party is Laiks Pārmaiņām (Time for Changes). The initiator of the founding of this new party is Baltic Association – Transport and Logistics President Inga Antāne.

NATO: suspicions about Zapad 2017 were justified

NATO views its suspicions about Russian-Belarusian Zapad 2017 military exercises as well-justified, because their scale and geography were larger than what was officially stated.

Expert: Latvia’s electronic industry productivity index on a rise

Electronics industry is the most rapidly growing processing industry in Latvia. This industry’s turnover growth in Latvia has been more rapid than that of Europe and the rest of Baltic States, says manager of wholesale trade company Lemona Latvija Sergejs Nikiforovs.

Video: How to make white-water rafting more dangerous?

If you think white-water rafting is a piece of cake, you can try getting over some rapids on six rafts.

Kaimiņš: Lembergs is Latvia’s biggest misfortune

It is no secret to anyone that the parliamentary committee in charge of investigating Oligarch case has so-called experts that are closely associated with infamous Ventspils politician Aivars Lembergs or his family. In an interview to BNN, Saeima member Artuss Kaimiņš shared his opinion about the latest scandalous development associated with Oligarch talks. He calls Lembergs Latvia’s biggest misfortune.