bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Ceturtdiena 27.07.2017 | Name days: Marta, Dita
LithuaniaLithuania

Lithuania’s Constitutional Court: legislators need to redraw constituencies. Will they before Seimas election?

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(+1 rating, 1 votes)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

Linas Jegelevičius for the BNN

With just a year to go, Lithuania’s electoral system has been shaken up to the core. After the Constitutional Court’s ruling that the present voter determination order is flawed and cause disparities in voter numbers in Lithuania’s 71 constituencies, therefore incompliant with the Constitution, Lithuanian MPs face dilemma: embrace the decision and hurriedly overhaul the system or touch it up slightly before the elections.

Among the new legislative initiatives is one proposing to abolish the country’s multiple-mandate electoral system.

Too many disparities

To explain, the disparities that the Court pointed out to are about exodus, large emigration, which many rural constituencies left semi-deserted. In some of them, the actual number of voters is twice lower than in urban constituencies. Therefore the flawed practice when the fate of a mandate, i.e. parliamentary seat, is determined by under-populated electoral districts.

Until now, Lithuanian voters pick up 70 MPs through voting in single-member electoral districts and 71 parliamentarians would come from the so-called party lists in which voters have to ticka single candidate’s name.

The court ruling is binding and puts a big pressure on Lithuanian lawmakers to make necessary adjustments before the next general elections in October next year.

«The ruling has brought much confusion among the party candidates throughout the region. Some candidates in adjacent districts around have been already confirmed and, having secured the slots, they were waiting for a kick-start of the electoral campaign. But now all has been shaken up and the process (of selecting candidates) is likely will have to be started all over in some constituencies,» Dainius Želvys, a councilman of Palanga Municipality in western Lithuania, told BNN.

Around third Lithuanian parliamentarians addressed the Constitutional Court.

Fluctuations reach 50 percent

The Court ruled that, in single-seat constituencies, the voter numbers can fluctuate from 0.8 to 1.2 percent from the average voter number set years ago. But in reality, the court emphasized, the difference is often at a staggering 20 percent, and the disparities in the largest and smallest constituencies can reach a whopping 50 percent.

With the same voters’ activity, the importance of a voter in a small electoral district is way more significant than in a large constituency, noted the Court.

To iron out the disparities, constituencies need to be redrawn, adding voters from larger ones to the smaller ones, the Constitutional Court says.

The chairman of the Central Electoral Commission, Zenonas Vaigauskas, says this could be done as early as by the end of 2015.

«The constituency boundaries are already redrawn, the project is ready and it only needs to be approved. We only need to make a final agreement. I think it will not be difficult to do, because the project has already been discussed. Not everyone is happy with it, because it changes the current constituencies cardinally,» Vaigauskas was quoted as saying by Lithuanian media.

Naujininkai electoral district in Lithuanian capital is the largest constituency, encompassing around 50,000 voters and the smallest ones contain only 28,000-30,000 voters.

Two bills are submitted, more drafts likely ahead

As many as two draft bills aiming to re-shape constituencies have been crafted- one of them includes minimal measures for the upcoming general elections in 2016, while the other, if enacted, would radically redraw voting districts and is planned for the parliamentary elections in 2020.

With the latter proposal in effect, three new constituencies would be added in Vilnius, where the density of population is way bigger than elsewhere in the country; in Kaunas, meanwhile, one electorate district would be abolished, the same would happen in Šiauliai. Some boundaries of other constituencies would be also considerably twitched around, according to the draft.

Both schemes have been under fire in Lithuanian parliament, but according to Vaigauskas, the more radical projectis the one that will have to be adopted following the constitutional ruling.

Following it, more proposals on how to reform the country’s electoral system are expected.

From praise to doubts

Prime Minister and chairman of Lithuania’s Social Democrat Party Algirdas Butkevičius believes that there is still time to make necessary adjustments before the parliamentary elections next year.

Meanwhile, the leader of the Liberal Movement party, Eligijus Masiulis, insists changes should be made as soon as possible and that «cities should have more single-seat constituencies.»

Seimas opposition leader, conservative Andrius Kubilius cast doubt whether adjustments in constituencies could be effectively carried out for the upcoming general elections.

Kubilius said that «not only strict bureaucratic procedures, but also stability and tradition play a very important role in democracy. The number of voters should not be the main factor.»

The leader of Homeland Union- Lithuanian Christian Democrats, also known as Conservatives, Gabrielius Landsbergis, also insists that both the political parties and society have to «respect» the constitutional ruling and put aside their personal and partisan interests in implementing the reform.

«I believe that the final election results will depend on the voters’ will, but not on the politicians’ calculations and attempts to move the (electoral district) boundaries in favor of their political intentions. If because of narrow partisan and personal interests the Central Electoral Commission fails to implement the constitutional ruling, there would be a big danger that results of 2016 Seimas elections are illegitimate and this would trigger a constitutional crisis,» Landsbergis said.

Leader of the ruling Labour Party Valentinas Mazuronis thinks that the disproportion of voters should be corrected, although with one year left before the elections, doing so now would be a hasty move.

Ramifications of constitutional ruling

The discussions have taken an unexpected course on Wednesday, October 21, when the Speaker of Lithuanian Parliament, Loreta Graužinienė, a representative of Labour Party, has proposed to entirely scrap single-seat constituencies.

If the proposal were enacted, Lithuanian voters would need to select 141 names- that is the number of seats in Lithuanian Parliament has- from party lists provided for voters in a parliamentary election.

«There’s an opinion in our fraction that we need to alter the electoral system and follow the example of other European countries, like Latvia and Estonia, for example, have. Now we has this system in Lithuania when part of Seimas members are elected one way and the others the other way,» the Speaker told.

She added that the parliamentary fractions were obligated to come up with their own proposals (regarding the election system) in a week.

«We agreed that we will go back to our fractions and will have discussions there and then all will assemble in my office again in a week, by when, hopefully, we will have a clearer position what way to take,» Graužinienė said.

Some other MPs have registered their proposals which will be reviewed by the fractions.

Some of the initiatives, like Social Democrat Juozas Bernatonis’s, date back to 2013, when the lawmaker proposed to divide all the constituencies into ten electoral districts in which parties would submit their candidate lists for voters.

Quick thinking- and actions- are needed

All those who participated in the hearing held by the Speaker agreed that changes to constituencies’ boundaries need to be done as soon as possible, otherwise the election’s legitimacy may be put in question. Besides, some fear, if that ever were the case, courts would get jammed with numerous plaintiffs’ lawsuits.

Vaigauskas, of the Central Electoral Commission, who also participated in the hearing, was reluctant to prognosticate whether the Seimas will strike accord on the changes to the electoral system in an expedient fashion.

«If Seimas will ever determine to adopt a new electoral system, it will be characteristic to new democracy states, like Latvia, Estonia, Poland and that one of Sweden. Only Belarus among our closest neighbours has electoral system like ours,» Vaigauskas said, referring to the second scenario, which envisions abolishment of single-mandate electoral districts.

Election results will be less predictable

If Seimas braces up for the redrawing of constituencies, the results of the parliamentary elections will be less predictable, believe many Lithuanian political analysts.

«The results will certainly be harder to predict and for the candidates, who have been competing in the same constituencies for years, something can change,» Mažvydas Jastramskis, a political analyst, says.

He believes that, following the ruling by the Constitutional Court, there will be established more single-seat districts in urban territories and third of those in rural locations will disappear.

«If this happens, I believe this can play into hands of the Conservatives and Liberals,» the analyst predicted.

Meanwhile, Alvydas Nikžentaitis, a commentator and historian by profession, doubts whether the Seimas will brave up for any substantial change of the electoral system, especially that it could turn up some unpredictability.

«Knowing how slow the parties can be with decisions, I really doubt whether they will now start turning head over heels, especially that decisions on the system would work against the interests of parties. Social Democrats had submitted a draft on the constituency reform three years ago, but they have not pursued it until now,» the commentator told BNN. He added: «If whenever passed, the redrawing of constituency boundaries would not be in the best interests of right-centre parties».

Ref: 020/111.111.111.2841


Leave a reply

Juncker to held stop food discrimination of EU's eastern members

Reacting to criticism from Slovakia, Bulgaria and other European Union member states on differences in food product quality in Eastern Europe, the head of the EU's executive body, Jean-Claude Juncker, has pledged to help end the «totally unacceptable» practice.

Property purchase and rent trends are similar among Baltic States

Currently the proportion of standard apartments in Riga in comparison with new projects is rather significant – while the number of standard apartments in the capital is 3,200, new projects are limited to only 300 buildings, according to information compiled DNB Bank and Ober-Haus on apartment demand in Latvia and Baltics.

Construction costs in Latvia up 0.2%

Compared to May, the level of construction costs in Latvia increased by 0.2 % in June 2017.

Beer brewers: many will lose jobs because of increased excise tax on beer

If the Saeima supports the initiative on increasing excise tax on beer by 50% this Thursday, 27 July, the number of people employed in the beer industry will decrease 30%, which will especially impact residents of Latvia’s regions, according to Latvian Breweries Union.

Helsinki-Riga route to be tested by Tallink

Estonian ferry and cruise company Tallink is testing this week the interest of passengers to take a cruise trip from Helsinki to Riga.

Where is the piece of land Duklavs’ associates wanted 15 million for?

Ir magazine has surveyed several hectares of land on Daugava River’s left bank, specifically within the territory of Riga Freeport, to find the piece of land that was mentioned by Agriculture Minister Janis Duklavs during his conversation with other politicians in Ridzene hotel.

Opinion: candidates of the last presidency have all been intellectually weak

One of this summer’s hottest and most discussed piece of news was the proposal to allow residents to elect the country’s president. Latvian President Raimonds Vejonis’ 22 June speech to the parliament, in which he proposed allowing the people to elect the president in 2019, caused even more discussions.

Flat rental fraud increases in Estonia

Police in Estonia have observed a increase in fraud complaints in the area of rental flats as fraudsters typically ask for prepayments and deposits for listed flats they do not own.

Latvian troops to participate in Northern Strike exercises in USA

Throughout 27 July – 14 August, more than 70 troops of Latvian Armed Forces will be taking part in Northern Strike 2017 joint land and air exercises organized by Michigan National Guard in USA.

Delna: if the prime minister chooses to stifle emotions, the president should step up

On Wednesday, 26 July, Delna received a response letter from Prime Minister Maris Kucinskis to Delna’s previous letter, in which the organization requested the dismissal of Agriculture Minister Janis Duklavs.

Saeima supports tax reform laws in final reading

Saeima’s Budget and Finance Committee has concluded work on tax reform laws, supporting them in the final reading. Part of the proposals on additional benefits and multiple other matters will be put off for a later date.

Latvian Shipping Company sells its office building on Elizabetes Street 1

On Tuesday, 25 July, Latvian Shipping Company signed an agreement on the sale of its current office building. The buyer and the next owner of the house will be the United Arab Emirates, who purchased the six-story building on Elizabetes Street 1 in Riga for the needs of the embassy, as confirmed by the company.

Farmers Saeima: beef industry in Latvia is not sufficiently developed

Farmers Saeima believes Latvia’s beef industry is not sufficiently developed, and existing farms have not sufficiently stabilized – many farms have major debt. Because of that any kind of support for the industry is welcome.

Puce: Latvia should ratify Istanbul Convention without reservations

For Latvia’s Development political party has turned to Welfare Ministry with a request to ratify Istanbul Convention without any corrections as soon as possible, BNN was informed by the party’s representatives.

More than half of Latvian businessmen work on weekend; study shows

Businessmen normally spend eight hours and five minutes on work every day. More than 58% of Latvian businessmen also work on weekends, according to data from the latest Citadele Index study.

Farmers: crop yield this year will be positive thanks to weather

In Zemgale, crop harvest began a week ago. Harvest of winter crops is almost over. Harvests elsewhere in Latvia will commence no sooner than August, farmers say.

Murniece offers UGF to consider replacing Duklavs

«The policy is that, considering Duklavs’ involvement in Ridzene talks, the Union of Greens and Farmers should consider ways of resolving the situation,» says Saeima speaker Inara Murniece.

Chinese-Russian navy drill takes place in Baltic Sea

Russian and Chinese navies have launched their first joint military drill in the Baltic Sea raising concern to NATO member states Estonia, Latvia, Lithuania and Poland, cautious of Russia's aggressive actions in Ukraine.

Tax loss forecast by Estonian food producers dismissed by Finance Minister

Estonian Finance Minister Toomas Tõniste has rejected the grim forecast published by the Estonian Food Industry Association this week that the state budget would lose 170 million euros in tax revenue in 2018 due to excise tax hikes.

Antane: excise tax for diesel fuel should be reduced, not increased

«Unfortunately, when making the decision to increase excise tax rate for diesel fuel, the government did not consider all possible risks this decision could bring to the transport and logistics industry and the country’s economy as a whole,» BNN was told by President of Baltic Association – Transport and Logistics Inga Antane.

Association: rapid increase of excise tax would cause dramatic rise of smuggling activity

National Association for Tobacco Product Manufacturers is confused about Finance Ministry’s submitted proposals for tax reform that provide for raising excise tax on cigarettes by 11% instead of previously planned 5.5%.

UK plans to ban petrol and diesel vehicles

In an attempt to curb air pollution the UK plans to set the goal to ban from 2040 new diesel and petrol engine cars and vans.

Members of Saeima delegated to the investigative committee in charge of Oligarch case

Andrejs Judins from Unity, Martins Sics from Latvian Association of Regions, Igors Pimetovs from Harmnony, Ritvars Jansons from VL-TB/LNNK, Inguna Sudraba from To Latvia from the Heart and Ainars Mezulis from the Union of Greens and Farmers have been delegated to the parliamentary committee for the investigation of Oligarch case.

U.S. legislators back additional sanctions on Russia

The House of Representatives of the U.S. Congress has adopted imposing additional sanctions on Russia, North Korea and Iran, even though U.S. President Donald Trump has opposed fresh sanctions on Russia.

Government allows Bite Lietuva to become the owner of TV3, LNT and Star FM

On Tuesday, 25 July, the Cabinet of Ministers permitted Lithuanian company UAB BITE Lietuva to acquire decisive influence in Latvian media companies TV 3 Latvia, LNT and Star FM.