bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Sunday 22.01.2017 | Name days: Austris
LatviaLatvia

SA: in Citadele’s sale, the government made itself a hostage of its own decision

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RUSelling for the highest possible price has always been a priority in the sale of Citadele Bank. At the same time, conditions voiced by the European Commission and European Reconstruction and Development Bank were not taken into account sufficiently.

Those conditions limited that government’s options in making independent decisions in the bank’s selling process and could influence opinions of potential buyers about the bank’s value, as noted by the State Audit.

As a result of that, the bank’s sale was delayed to the last moment, leaving the state no room to manoeuvrer to establish favourable conditions for the sale. SA concluded in its report on the sale of state owned capital shares in Citadele Bank.

It was clear at the moment when Parex Bank was taken over that it was an unprecedented act for establishment of financial stability in the country. Knowing the importance of the deal for the country, its size and potential impact on the state budget, the government should have created special rules to govern decision-making processes in relation to the restructuring of Parex Bank, including the sale of Citadele Bank. Instead of that, the government decided to sort out the structure of the deal to comply with regulations stated in the Law on Governance of Capital Shares of a Public Person and Capital Companies, which did not come close to secure accessibility of all necessary tools to ensure realization of state interests, SA noted.

The government’s decision states that the Privatization Agency became the shareholder in Citadele Bank. As time went by, the Privatization Agency made no decisions in relation to the bank’s sale process. Moreover – board members were provided with guarantee contracts that provided for the compensation of any losses from the state side should the losses arise. The government made all conceptual decisions in relation to the bank’s sale process. The Privatization Agency served as a mailbox between the government and associated consultants. The latter were the ones to develop solutions for the government’s decisions. Ministries provided no opinions on the deal. Opinions provided by the Bank of Latvia were not taken into account for inexplicable reasons, as concluded by SA.

Auditors believe the sale of Citadele Bank provided Privatization Agency with EUR 74.7 million. Nothing of this amount was left for the state budget, because EUR 76.97 million, the amount that exceeded the EUR 74.7 million received as a result of the sale, was paid to the European Reconstruction and Development Bank.

The Privatization Agency’s realized management of Parex Bank’s restructuring, including the formation of Citadele Bank’s and its sale resulted in the state being paid at least EUR 6.5 million. EUR 5.5 million of this amount was paid to consultants. The Privatization Agency could not provide a report on the use of the remaining EUR 1 million, SA reports.

«Why is it possible to conclude that the state could have earned more? First of all, based on conclusions made by multiple independent experts, the bank’s value was 25 to 75 million euros higher that the selling price. Secondly, selling the bank at the last moment put the government in a situation when it was no longer possible to defend Latvia’s interests. To complete the deal within terms coordinated with the European Committee and realize commitments stated in cooperation agreements compiled by the European Reconstruction and Development Bank, it was necessary to accept conditions put forward by partners without questions. The State Audit also had an opportunity to learn that among contenders were also investors who offered higher prices. Nevertheless, to preserve reputation, the government should have assessed the price in accordance with other condition. Had all of those factors been taken into account, with the sales strategy planned in advance, it is possible that it would have been possible to sell the bank without delaying the sale process,» – SA reported.

The sale of Citadele Bank is not the only example of a large-scale national deal that does not provide confidence about sufficient protection of state interests. Other examples include Liepājas Metalurgs, airBaltic and upcoming decisions in regards to the future of state owned shares in Lattelecom, LMT, Rail Baltica and other matters that not only impact the national economy, but also require considerable financial investments, the State Audit notes, hoping conclusions made in the report will be taken into account and help prevent any future mistakes of that kind.

Ref: 102.109.109.6099


Leave a reply

People no longer believe in their own country, because they associate it with people who make decisions

The biggest threat to Latvia is the fact that society, including state officials, is afraid. People are afraid of change, afraid of voicing their thoughts (thoughts that often do not comply with the politically correct stance), afraid of being misunderstood. Fear makes it harder to develop. It limits people’s internal freedom. Such is the opinion Inga Antane, president of Baltic Association – Transport and Logistics and sworn attorney of Triniti law firm, explained in her interview to Atbalsts.

Expert: «Lithuania’s renewed National Security Strategy is a «hodgepodge»

This week, the Lithuanian Parliament has overwhelmingly approved a renewed National Security Strategy, laying out 14 major hazards and risk factors to national security.

Industry: advertisements contribute the entire economy of the European Union

Every euro invested in advertisement has seven times the influence on a country’s GDP. Every one euro brings seven euros in return to the country’s GDP, as emphasized by Latvian Advertising Association, noting that advertisement sector contributes to employment in all of the European Union.

Six deputies applied with administrative penalties in Saeima’s autumn session

According to information provided to the parliament, six deputies were applied with administrative penalties during Saeima’s autumn session.

Slower economic growth for Estonia forecast – at 2.2% - for 2017

The economic growth of Estonia in 2017 will be slower than previously expected, Swedbank economists have announced lowering their previous economic forecast for the Baltic country by 0.2% to 2.2%.

Latvian and Lithuanian authorities dismantle two criminal groups

Latvian State Revenue Service’s Finance Police has successfully apprehended two organized crime groups that caused significant damage to the state budget in 2015 and 2016 by realizing different VAT fraud schemes.

Estonia to drop special pensions, push forward sweeping pension reforms

The Estonian government has decided to drop special pensions and to push forward with plans regarding other significant changes in the pension system, including tying the retirement age to the average life expectancy.

KNAB performs inspection about Jakrins’ approval in the board of Rīgas satiksme

Corruption Prevention and Combating Bureau intends to inspect if the approval of acting head of Riga City Council’s Transport Department Emils Jakrins in the management board of Rīgas satiksme had any signs of breach of good management principles.

Chinese GDP up 6.7% in 2016

World’s second largest economy has seen a 6.7% growth in 2016, Chinese official data show, which indicate that the gross-domestic-product increase has been slower than the 6.9% seen in 2015 and the slowest since 1990.

Dozens buried in Italy’s avalanche-stricken hotel

Italy has been shaken by a number of earthquakes this week, one of which has triggered an avalanche burying a mountain hotel, where at least two people have been found dead and dozens more a searched for through rubble and snow.

Weekends to experience frost and thaw; drivers urged to be careful

Weather in Latvia will not be stable in the next couple of days – cloudy weather with some precipitation will be mixed with periods of clear sky, according to State Environmental, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

Logistics Industry Council assesses results of 16+1 summit

Experts say container cargoes have the potential to bring major contribution to the logistics sector. With that, LDz Logistics intends to continue organizing the next container train from China, as well as cooperate with partners from Belarus and China in the context of the Great Stone industrial park, as BNN was informed by Transport Ministry’s representative Ilze Greiskalna.

Parliament supports amendments to avoid expensive land-measuring actions

It will no longer be necessary to prepare land border plan for entry of land units in the Land Book. It will help save budget funds, as it will not be necessary to perform land-measuring actions, as reported by Saeima press-service.

CP supervisors concerned about Latvijas Gāze’s contract terms

The Competition Council is concerned about Latvijas Gāze’s behaviour in the process of liberalization of the country’s gas market. Economy Ministry has submitted a draft of the Gas Trade and Use Rules to the Cabinet of Ministers Committee for review.

Germany seeks clarity from Trump’s government, to boost military spending

Berlin has emphasised plans to increase defence spending after facing criticism from upcoming U.S. President Donald Trump on NATO countries not meeting their spending commitments.

Saeima re-elects Elita Krumina as State Auditor

On Thursday, 19 January, the Saeima re-elected Elita Krumina in the post of State Auditor.

Saeima supports formation of aircraft passenger data registry to combat terrorism

On Thursday, 19 January, Latvia’s Saeima approved the Aircraft Passenger Data Processing Law in the final reading. This will form the passenger data registry.

Milk retail price in Estonia reaches 55 cents per litre after to price hikes

After a long period of low milk purchase prices in Estonia, milk retail prices in the Baltic country have increased twice, reaching the point where famers receive just enough to cover milk production costs.

Ventspils Freeport carries Lembergs around with luxurious car worth EUR 156,000

In spite of a 16.44% turnover decline, Ventspils Freeport bought a lux-class Audi A8L W12 for EUR 156,000 last year. It’s only known passenger so far has been the formally suspended chairman of Ventspils City Council Aivars Lembergs, as reported by Latvijas Avīze.

Estonia concludes bilateral defence framework deal with Finland

Estonia and Finland have signed a bilateral defence cooperation framework agreement aiming for closer and more regular cooperation in the field by the neighbouring countries.

Biden: Wealthiest 1% does not pay enough in taxes

The «top 1% is not carrying their weight», outgoing U.S. vice-president, Joe Biden evaluated at the World Economic Forum, insisting the world's wealthiest that they do not pay enough in taxes.

Latvia and Japan sign convention on attraction of foreign investments

In Tokyo, Latvian Finance Minister Dana Reizniece-Ozola and Japanese Foreign Ministry’s Parliamentary Vice-Minister Motome Takisawa signed a convention between the two countries on double taxation prevention for income tax.

FM: problems with real estate tax cannot be resolved with tax rate corridor

Real estate tax benefits for housing area could be applied for each person declared living in each respective house. Each benefit can be applied to the building and land, Finance Ministry’s representative Aleksis Jarockis reported on conclusions made by the work group responsible for amendments.

Turkey’s New Year’s terrorist admits choosing nightclub randomly

The main suspect of the attack in Istanbul, which left 39 people dead during New Year’s celebrations, had selected randomly the place of attack.

WhatsApp to be provided with bank-contacting functionality

Continuing the digitization process and studying customer habits more intently, it is planned to allow customers resolve matters related to finances using WhatsApp, DNB Bank reports.

When do you pay fines for speeding?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

Polls Archive



Category feed: Feed: