bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Monday 29.05.2017 | Name days: Raivis, Raivo, Maksis
LatviaLatvia

SA: in Citadele’s sale, the government made itself a hostage of its own decision

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RUSelling for the highest possible price has always been a priority in the sale of Citadele Bank. At the same time, conditions voiced by the European Commission and European Reconstruction and Development Bank were not taken into account sufficiently.

Those conditions limited that government’s options in making independent decisions in the bank’s selling process and could influence opinions of potential buyers about the bank’s value, as noted by the State Audit.

As a result of that, the bank’s sale was delayed to the last moment, leaving the state no room to manoeuvrer to establish favourable conditions for the sale. SA concluded in its report on the sale of state owned capital shares in Citadele Bank.

It was clear at the moment when Parex Bank was taken over that it was an unprecedented act for establishment of financial stability in the country. Knowing the importance of the deal for the country, its size and potential impact on the state budget, the government should have created special rules to govern decision-making processes in relation to the restructuring of Parex Bank, including the sale of Citadele Bank. Instead of that, the government decided to sort out the structure of the deal to comply with regulations stated in the Law on Governance of Capital Shares of a Public Person and Capital Companies, which did not come close to secure accessibility of all necessary tools to ensure realization of state interests, SA noted.

The government’s decision states that the Privatization Agency became the shareholder in Citadele Bank. As time went by, the Privatization Agency made no decisions in relation to the bank’s sale process. Moreover – board members were provided with guarantee contracts that provided for the compensation of any losses from the state side should the losses arise. The government made all conceptual decisions in relation to the bank’s sale process. The Privatization Agency served as a mailbox between the government and associated consultants. The latter were the ones to develop solutions for the government’s decisions. Ministries provided no opinions on the deal. Opinions provided by the Bank of Latvia were not taken into account for inexplicable reasons, as concluded by SA.

Auditors believe the sale of Citadele Bank provided Privatization Agency with EUR 74.7 million. Nothing of this amount was left for the state budget, because EUR 76.97 million, the amount that exceeded the EUR 74.7 million received as a result of the sale, was paid to the European Reconstruction and Development Bank.

The Privatization Agency’s realized management of Parex Bank’s restructuring, including the formation of Citadele Bank’s and its sale resulted in the state being paid at least EUR 6.5 million. EUR 5.5 million of this amount was paid to consultants. The Privatization Agency could not provide a report on the use of the remaining EUR 1 million, SA reports.

«Why is it possible to conclude that the state could have earned more? First of all, based on conclusions made by multiple independent experts, the bank’s value was 25 to 75 million euros higher that the selling price. Secondly, selling the bank at the last moment put the government in a situation when it was no longer possible to defend Latvia’s interests. To complete the deal within terms coordinated with the European Committee and realize commitments stated in cooperation agreements compiled by the European Reconstruction and Development Bank, it was necessary to accept conditions put forward by partners without questions. The State Audit also had an opportunity to learn that among contenders were also investors who offered higher prices. Nevertheless, to preserve reputation, the government should have assessed the price in accordance with other condition. Had all of those factors been taken into account, with the sales strategy planned in advance, it is possible that it would have been possible to sell the bank without delaying the sale process,» – SA reported.

The sale of Citadele Bank is not the only example of a large-scale national deal that does not provide confidence about sufficient protection of state interests. Other examples include Liepājas Metalurgs, airBaltic and upcoming decisions in regards to the future of state owned shares in Lattelecom, LMT, Rail Baltica and other matters that not only impact the national economy, but also require considerable financial investments, the State Audit notes, hoping conclusions made in the report will be taken into account and help prevent any future mistakes of that kind.

Ref: 102.109.109.6099


Leave a reply

Week in Lithuania. PM: Coalition isn't the best

Lithuanian Prime Minister Saulius Skvernelis, whose government has been in office for half a year, says that the Lithuanian Farmers and Greens Union and the Lithuanian Social Democratic Party differ in their philosophies and approaches to many issues.

BNN summary of the week: Estonian minister disapproves of NATO; Latvia’s tax system lags behind

BNN offers a summary of this week’s topical news in a variety of categories: Business; Change; Future; Decline; Truth and Growth.

Municipal elections 2017: what do people say?

With municipal elections gradually coming close, BNN offers a compilation of opinions provided by experts from different industries. Short answers consist of thoughts about specific municipalities that affect respondents directly, and municipal administrations in general – what people expect from officials and what changes they expect from elections.

Trade of natural gas to legal clients in Latvia commences

Trade of natural gas to legal clients in Latvia has commenced. Latvenergo’s Elektrum product offers fixed-price contracts for 12-month supply period. The first gas supply contracts have been signed with clients in Latvia, the company reports.

Murniece: the biggest strength of Latvia’s parliament is public involvement

The biggest strength of Latvia’s parliament is the involvement of the public in resolution efforts of matters associated with child and women’s rights, the rights of disabled people, as well as security, tax policy and the European Union, says Saeima speaker Inara Murniece.

Corruption on decline in Lithuania, yet still remains troublesome

To wrap up the findings of a new corruption research ordered by the Special Investigation Service, an institution dealing with financial crimes in Lithuania, the situation is largely improving, yet not as fast as the service wishes.

Ventspils signs agreement with Chinese-Belarusian industrial park Great Stone

Vetnspils Freeport Authority and Ventspils High Technology Park signed an agreement yesterday with Chinese-Belarusian industrial park Great Stone, which is the largest infrastructure development project in Belarus, as reported by the freeport’s representatives.

Resignation filed by arrested Tallinn Deputy Mayor

The Deputy Mayor of the Estonian capital has stepped down from office after being arrested as part of a criminal case into violations of procedural restrictions of Tallinn procurement tenders.

Residents: situation in Latvia is developing in a wrong manner

54% of residents believe the situation in Latvia is currently developing in a wrong manner. A similar situation is noted in relation to the evaluation of the government’s work. 75% of respondents are critical about the government’s work. Only 17% of respondents are positive about the government’s work, according to results of Baltic International Bank Latvian Barometer.

Finance Minister: we have to be ready for flexibility in the reform plan

Currently we have to progress forward with the intended tax reform and prepare for a degree of flexibility, says Latvian Finance Minister Dana Reizniece-Ozola.

Zarins: unlike healthcare workers, Latvia’s roads are crumbling silently

Saeima deputy Ivars Zarins has submitted a proposal that offers restoring State Roads Fund and providing it with funding of 80% of excise tax for oil products. It is also proposed to divert income from vehicle operation tax and road use fee.

Price of oil slides 5%, though exporters decide to uphold production restrictions

Oil price has dropped by around five percent, even though oil-exporting countries have decided to maintain production limits until spring 2018.

Experts: role of free trade agreements to increase – especially with Asia

Latvian businessmen are already sufficiently active in several Asian markets. Their experience shows – these markets have great potential, according to representatives of the European Parliament’s Information Bureau.

Trump steps up pressure on NATO’s «indebted»

All NATO member states should pay their fair share of military expenses, has stated U.S. President Donald Trump in a meeting of NATO member states in Brussels.

Sunday expected to be summer-like hot in Latvia

This Sunday is expected to be summer-like hot, whereas the week after will be cold and rainy, as reported by Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

Pensioner guide: old people are isolated from society in Latvia

«In my experience with social care, I was surprised by the dominating belief that the only thing old people need is elementary care – some food, a wash and a walk outside. Psychology of old people is something completely alien to people in Latvia,» says initiator of Pensioners Guide in Latvia Nelli Skadina.

SEB: reimbursements paid to nearly 340 loan clients over the past five years

In five years since the signing of the first loan payment insurance contract, reimbursements have been paid to nearly 240 SEB Bank clients who took loans and experienced unexpected difficulties after.

Number of tourists to Riga up 7% in 2017

In the first three months of 2017, a total of 263.5 thousand people were serviced in Riga’s hotels and tourist accommodations. 221.3 thousand of those tourists were foreign guests. Compared with the same period of last year, the number of tourists has grown 7%.

Estonian capital’s Deputy Mayor arrested over waste management dealings

The Deputy Mayor of Tallinn, Arvo Sarapuu, accused of deliberately violating procedural restrictions an especially large scale as part of a criminal case, has been arrested by the Estonian Internal Security Service.

Saeima ratifies convention on restriction for the use of mercury

On Thursday, 25 May, Latvia’s Saeima ratified Minamata Convention on Mercury. The objective of the convention is protecting people and the environment against anthropogenic emissions and leaks of mercury.

Europe experienced foreign investment records last year

Last year, Europe attracted a record large volume of foreign investments with 5,845 new direct investment projects, which is 15% more than the year before, according to results of EY European Attractiveness Survey.

Electric car charging network expands in Latvia to promote «greener thinking»

The once long-away dream of having cars that run on alternative fuel is now a reality – a special infrastructure network keeps expanding in Latvia to make electric cars more popular, says Motors Latvia BMW Group manager Ivars Norvelis.

Estonian Minister steps down after questioning NATO membership

Estonian Minister of Public Affairs Mihhail Korb has stated he resigns from office after saying he is not in favour of NATO membership.

Construction of a fish freezer commences at Ventspils Freeport

Construction work has commenced in Ventspils industrial territory on Talsu Street 200. Latvian National Fisheries Producers' Organisation plans to build a fish freezer facility there, as reported by Ventspils Freeport.

EC: there is a risk tax reform will increase inequality

There is a risk that Latvian government’s proposed tax reform will increase income inequality in the country instead of lowering it, said head of European Commission’s office in Latvia Inna Steinbuka.