Latviski English По-русски
Ceturtdiena 19.10.2017 | Name days: Drosma, Drosmis, Elīna

Šlesers’ actual role in the signing of contract with Ryanair is revealed

(+1 rating, 1 votes)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RUDetails regarding the signing of the unfavourable contract between Ryanair and Riga International airport have surfaced in the London Court of International Arbitration.

On top of that, information regarding Ainārs Šlesers’ actual role in the signing of the questionable contract between Ryanair and Riga International airport, and that of other officials, has also surfaced in the London court, as reported by Pietiek.

Šlesers was the one who extended the proposal to Ryanair to include a single agreed fee in the contract. This is demonstrated e-mail correspondence between Šlesers and Ryanair over the course of summer 2003 – spring 2004.

The Corruption Prevention and Combating Bureau had previously unsuccessfully investigated Šlesers’ role in the contract’s signing process. Šlesers always claimed that even though the contract guaranteed lower service costs for Ryanair flights, it would only benefit Latvia’s economy by increasing the number of serviced passengers and developing Latvia’s tourism sector.

Based on testimony from current and former officials and previously unpublished e-mail correspondence of Šlesers’ political office, Ryanair and Riga International airport, Latvian lawyers informed the London court that the airport’s Board had opposed the signing of the contract with Ryanair, because they knew it would lead to considerable losses.

The court of arbitration had basically agreed that it was Šlesers, not the airport’s Board, who was the main driving force of the signing of the contract. This did not, however, affect the court’s ruling. It was decided that the contract is in force and is to be interpreted in favour of Ryanair.

The airport’s position in the court of arbitration was that ‘Šlesers personally headed talks about conditions of the contract and made the airport sign it’. Because Transport Ministry is a holder of shares in Riga airport, it has legal and practical means of exacting influence on the airport in order for the latter to accept conditions agreed upon by Ryanair and Šlesers. The airport’s Board had no other choice but to follow Transport Ministry’s order to sign the contract in 2004.

Andis Damlics, who was and remains a member of the airport’s Board, testified in the London court that Šlesers was directly involved in talks with Ryanair. He added that the airport’s Board had opposed multiple conditions of the contract.

In spring or early summer of 2004, Transport Minister Šlesers’ office had sent the airport a project of the contract, giving a political order for the airport to sign it. A meeting was held shortly after receiving the contract. During this meeting, Šlesers, the management of the airport and Ryanair administrative director David O’Brian reached an agreement regarding several amendments to the contract’s conditions. However, some time later the airport received a new version of the contract. As it turned out, it did not include a single one of the previously agreed upon amendments and was no different from the initial version of the contract.

On June 27th, 2003, then the Commercial Director of Ryanair Conan henry wrote to Šlesers, expressing his satisfaction with their meeting in Dublin. He also expressed his interest in performing Ryanair flights to Riga. However, before the project could progress, he requested a written approval of Ryanair’s commercial conditions (thуy were added to the letter he sent to Šlesers). This was followed up by a meeting with Šlesers on November 7th, 2003, dгring which the two sides discussed flight routes, dates and costs.

Following talks that lasted for months, one final meeting between Ryanair management and Šlesers was held in Riga on April 23rd, 2004. After this meeting, David O’Brian wrote to Šlesers that Ryanair agreed to ‘his offer regarding a single „all inclusive” fee of EUR 4.5 per passenger’.

On May 14thm 2004, Šlesers sent a proposal to Ryanair regarding a project with airport costs. In letter sent a bit later, Šlesers extended an offer to Ryanair to make Riga its base if the airline can guarantee 500,000 passengers a year.

The court process also reviewed a correspondence between Damlics and Ryanair manager David Usher, which took place in between July 9th- 15th, 2004. In this correspondence, the airport’s representative expressed concern over the fact that air navigation services in the terminal zone were also included in the contract. This angered Ryanair, and on April 22nd Usher wrote to the airport’s Board, adding Šlesers as one of the recipients as well, noting that ‘the last document sent by Ryanair does not fully comply with the agreement that was reached in Šlesers’ office on July 7th’.

The inclusion of air navigation service costs in the single price was the main reason for the court process. According to the documents that surfaced during the court process, the inclusion of these costs was done with Šlesers’ direct involvement. The airport opposed doing this.

The London arbitration court concluded that Šlesers’ involvement in talks regarding contract conditions and the airport Board’s opposition of them shows that Transport Ministry was ‘more than a supervisor’. There is plenty of evidence to suggest Šlesers played a very active role in talks, as concluded by the court.

Ryanair management tried to justify the airport’s position, because representatives of the airport had signed the contract against their free will. Ryanair representatives had tried to reduce the impact of Šlesers’ influence over the contract – the minister’s active involvement only reflects the general desire of politicians to associate with this important business sector in order to gain political points. The airport’s position in the court was that Šlesers was the one who ordered the airport around and that his role was more than just coordinating the process.

Šlesers’ office had also coordinated amendments to the contract in autumn 2007. The court of arbitration also reviewed an e-mail that was sent by Šlesers’ advisor Natālija Džeina Maršāne to Ryanair executive director’s deputy Michael Cowley, offering changes to the structure of payments, which later led to amendment to the contract.

Therefore, on December 10th, 2007, there was a new contract that discriminated other airlines and offered additional benefits for Ryanair. This new contract stated that the airport is to cover the difference if Ryanair’s costs per passenger exceed the already low amount of EUR 4.5. November and December of 2007 were politically unstable. Under Aigars Kalvitis’ government, Šlesers was once again Transport Minister. Although this government was nearing its end and Šlesers had managed to remain in his post in Godmanis’ government, there were risks during preparations of amendments to Ryanair contract that political succession in Transport Ministry would not be followed.


Leave a reply

Sale of MTG’s business in Baltics to Providence concludes successfully

Wednesday, 18 October, marked the successful conclusion of the sale of Baltic assets owned by Swedish media concern Modern Times Group to Providence Equity Partners. From now on companies previously owned by MTG in Baltics will function as a single organization named All Media Baltics, as confirmed by the company’s manager Pierre Danon.

Estonian port company makes 29% more revenue in January-September

Estonian state port company Port of Tallinn has made the revenue in the amount of 99.1 million euros in the first nine months of 2017, which is a 29% increase compared to January-September in 2016.

42 gambling halls to be closed down in Riga in next five years

On Wednesday, 18 October, Riga City Council supported plans to close another 33 gambling halls in the city. With that, a total of 42 gambling halls will be liquidated in the next five year.

Latvia has the highest index of female CEOs among EU member states

The highest index of female CEOs among European Union member states belongs to Latvia – 47%. In total, only 33% of CEOs in EU were female last year, according to data from the Central Statistical Bureau of Latvia.

Survey: more and more people take notice of benefits provided by EU membership

65% of Latvian residents believe the country’s membership in the European Union has brought tangible benefits. A similar opinion was voiced by 64% of residents of all EU member states in the Eurobarometer study performed by the European Parliament.

17 persons in need of international aid are relocated to Latvia from Turkey

On Tuesday, 17 October, seventeen individuals, including nine children, in need of international protection were relocated to Latvia from Turkey as part of EU resettlement programme, as confirmed by Latvian Office of Citizenship and Migration Affairs.

BATL: to avoid crisis in transit sector, government and Transport Ministry must act

Latvian Prime Minister Māris Kučinskis’ led Latvian Ports, Transit and Logistics Council also supports Saeima’s National Economy Committee’s decision on the need for Transport Ministry to develop a long-term vision for the development of the country’s transit industry.

Psychologist: six-year-old children are not ready for school

«It is wrong to believe that the sooner a child starts going to school, the better their academic results will be. Reforms are performed aggressively, without asking pedagogues or other specialists for their opinion. We lack a comprehensive analysis of the current situation that would be based on studies, not international ratings,» says certified clinical psychologist and psychotherapist Jolanta Lamstere.

Klaipeda transport ticketing system to be installed by Estonian Ridango

In the Lithuanian port city of Klaipeda, Estonian firm Ridango has been selected for installing its technology on public transport.

Policeman in Malta posts he's happy about killing of journalist Galizia

In Malta, where an investigative journalist has been killed this week, a police sergeant has posted on Facebook he felt happy about her death and has been suspended from office a day after.

Exchange indexes reach new records; oil prices increase as well

Dow Jones Industrial Average and Standard & Poor’s 500 index reached new record-high values on Tuesday, 17 October. US dollar value before euro and Japanese yen increased.

Anti-corruption protesters in Ukraine push for reforms

Three protesters and a policeman have been injured in Kyiv, Ukraine, as a crowd of anti-corruption demonstrators voiced their demands for reforms aimed at tackling corruption in the country.

«Islamic state» capital conquered by Syrian Democratic Forces

An alliance of Syrian-Kurdish fighters, which is supported by the U.S., has stated it has gained full control of Raqqa, which has been for three years the centre of the «Islamic state» regime.

Poland hopes Turkey would join EU

Polish President Andrzej Duda meeting his Turkish counterpart shortly before an European Union-Turkey summit has expressed a hope that the country located at the cross-roads between Europe and the Middle East would join the EU some time.

Number of people at risk of poverty in Baltics in higher than the average in EU

The ratio of people subjected to poverty or social exclusion risk in Baltic States is higher than the average in the European Union, according to Eurostat data compiled for 26 out of 28 member states in 2016.

E-voting defended in Estonia after criticism from party leader

Responding to claims from a leader of an Estonian political party that the country’s e-voting system lacks transparency, the head of e-Government Academy’s e-democracy department explained it was possible that the voters of one party are more active e-voters than supporters of other parties.

Residents’ mood worsens; people become more critical about their finances

Over the course of the past month, residents’ general mood has worsened significantly – declines have been noted on all positions analysed by the survey. Residents were critical the most in the survey about their material state – the index in this category declined from -9 to -11, according to the latest Baltic International Bank Latvian Barometer.

Antāne: Saeima’s National Economy Committee has heard the transit industry’s cry

Inga Antāne, president of Baltic Association – Transport and Logistics, is satisfied with the decision that was made at the recent meeting of Saeima’s Economic, Agricultural, Environmental and Regional Policy Committee, asking the Transport Ministry to develop and present a sustainable development strategy for the industry and putting an emphasis on raising the competitiveness of railway tariffs.

Latvian’s attitude towards combating cancer in late stages seems irresponsible

The attitude towards combating cancer in late stages in Latvia remains very low, says former healthcare minister of Latvia Ingrīda Circene.

Hydrogen-powered transport technology – a reality in Latvia

There are plans to establish a hydrogen refuelling station in Riga before the end of 2017. A publicly available H2 refuelling station in Riga would secure an inter-state network of hydrogen refuelling stations: the closest other station will be established in Pernava, says Association Zero Emission Mobility Support chairman Arnis Bergs.

Estonian ministry to collect 270 000 euros from IT company over failure to build information system

Tieto Estonia, the Estonian branch of Finnish IT firm group Tieto will compensate the Estonian Ministry of Social Affairs 270,000 euros for the failure of the SKAIS2 project, the aim of which was the development of a new information system for the Estonian social insurance authority, but was deemed a failure in August.

Latvia invites Iran to act constructively to ensure security

Latvian Foreign Affairs Minister Edgars Rinkēvičs participated in a meeting of the EU Foreign Affairs Council in Luxembourg, where he discussed about the role of Iran in the region and the Joint Comprehensive Plan of Action in light of the upcoming report from US President Donald Trump to the Congress on Iran’s progress realizing the plan.

Vigil held in Malta over killing of investigative journalist

Several thousand people in Malta have taken part in a vigil held after news broke of the killing of an investigative journalist, who blamed Maltese government for corruption.

American exchange indexes reach record-high values; oil prices on the rise

In response to price rise of bank stocks, three leading indexes of US exchanges reached new record heights on Monday, 16 October. In addition, US Federal Reserve System manager Janet Yellen’s prediction regarding a soon inflation rise has increased confidence that base interest rate will increase in December.

54.14% more alcohol exported from Latvia; most of it to Russia

In the first eight months of 2017, a total of 102.259 million litres of alcoholic drinks was exported from Latvia, which is 54.14% more when compared with the same period of last year.