Latviski English По-русски
Monday 17.02.2020 | Name days: Konstance, Donats

Audit: Rail Baltica slowed by poor risk management and slow progress with municipalities

(No Ratings Yet)

Rail Baltica, State Audit, Latvia, report, Transport MinistryDelays and cost increase of Rail Baltica project is heavily affected by no risk management and no strategy, as well as slow progress in cooperation with municipalities and passive alienation of properties, Latvian State Audit (VK) concluded in its latest report.

Two weeks ago VK warned about the facts uncovered in the joint Latvian, Estonian and Lithuanian audit institutions’ report – the biggest infrastructure project in the history of independent Baltic States worth at least EUR 5.78 billion is behind schedule and its costs only keep increasing. In this international joint audit effort VK evaluated the contribution of Latvian institutions towards the failure to maintain schedule, which will unavoidably lead to increased costs.

Over the course of the first five years of the project’s implementation Latvia has used only near a quarter of the five-year funding. On top of that, a number of necessary tasks are behind schedule by one to four years, VK has concluded.

VK’s conclusions are the most critical when it comes to extension of construction terms for Riga Central Railway Station hub, Riga International Airport’s railway station and railway lines in Latvia’s central parts from two to four years because of missed deadlines with technical projects.

«These serious deviations from the plan show that at the beginning of the project we had only an ambitious commitment and no actual ability to manage the project. The project represents a serious test for all sides involved in it, but I would rather Latvia does not become the weak link,» admits Latvian State Auditor Elita Krūmiņa.

So far, Rail Baltica project has not been effectively managed in Latvia. A number of facts point to negligence and reliance on «higher powers», VK states.

Transport Ministry is responsible for Rail Baltica project in Latvia. Since 2014 the ministry has delegated formation of Rail Baltica infrastructure to LLC Eiropas Dzelzceļa līnijas. VK notes that the ministry’s supervision over the project has been insufficient so far.

Up to 2016 not a single Transport Ministry’s employee has had any direct duties in relation to the project’s supervision. In the two years that followed only one ministry worker was responsible for the project’s supervision. The four workers of a structural unit formed in 2018 basically worked on their own because there were no project management order and rules ready then. In 2017 the ministry’s high-rank coordination work group consisting of representatives from the ministry, LLC Eiropas Dzelzceļa līnijas and AS RB Rail met only four times, and the last meeting took place a year and a half ago, VK notes.

More on the topic: Rail Baltica employees: the project is in critical state due to poor management

«So far Transport Ministry and LLC Eiropas Dzelzceļa līnijas have not been able to agree on the project’s costs worth approximately EUR 170 000 in relation to the project’s general expenditures. Additionally, Transport Ministry’s developed mechanism for prevention of unrelated costs does not work,» VK concluded.

«Cooperation with municipalities, especially Riga City Council, has been neither regular nor sufficient. Sustainable Development Consultative Coordination Council, though composed, has convened only two times, and the last time was one and half-years ago,» explains VK.

Actual alienation of real estate properties has not even begun in Latvia

The pre-condition for design work completion and commencement of construction work is alienation of real estate property within the project’s territory. Rail Baltica project will affect at least 1 623 real estate properties, including 1 179 real estate properties owned by private and legal persons. Alienation of real estate properties in Latvia’s central territories was supposed to have had finished by the end of 2019. However, not a single previously initiated real estate alienation process had been completed by October 2019, leaving 97% of the process unfinished.

Delays with real estate alienation has also negatively affected other important tasks, such as development of the construction project’s guidelines by RB Rail, as well as measurement of the railway line’s  location and submission of amendment of related regulations for review to the government, VK explains.

For comparison – in Estonia the real estate alienation process’s completion had reached 26% by the end of 2018.

«The risk of Latvia failing to meet terms outlined in European Commission’s decision for co-financing of the project increases with each passing day,» VK warns.

VK believes there is no excuse for delays – real estate property alienation process is complicated, yes, but so far the progress of legislative amendments pushed by the ministry itself has been inexcusably slow.

Projects of Rail Baltica’s scale cannot be implemented without proper risk management

Neither Transport Ministry nor LLC Eiropas Dzelzceļa līnijas have seriously considered introducing an efficient risk-management mechanism, which is unacceptable for a project of such a scale, VK concludes.

«Effective management of such mechanisms also serves as an early-warning system that lets the government add timely corrections and reduce risks. For example, this is where amendments to regulations are needed – to speed up the alienation process. This problem was previously identified in the Transport Development Guidelines 2014-2020; LLC Eiropas Dzelzceļa līnijas also considers this a risk,» VK notes.

Read also: Estonia’s prime minister: Rail Baltica project unlikely to be finished on time

VK invites putting in practice actual risk assessment on the ministry’s level and prevent risk management problems observed at LLC Eiropas Dzelzceļa līnijas, improve overall project discipline and reduce increase of costs.

VK also intends to ask the Cabinet of Ministers to support Transport Ministry more intensely in the real estate alienation process, as well as ask the government form a system for supervision over strategically important projects and take over responsible ministry’s functions if need be.

Leave a reply

  1. Zerry says:

    Is this s surprise to someone? It could be good also to open a little more from where comes delays with municipalities? Someone asking pocket money?
    Anyway, architects have made a great job for nice presentations, but who will finsnce Riga central station and airport changes? Never told, or?

Week in Lithuania: retailer Maxima got in trouble, Turkish firm’s assets frozen, New Agency set up

Lithuania's concessions provided to the Polish business group Orlen, operating an oil refinery in Lithuania's Mažeikiai, have helped to improve bilateral relations but were not the key element in their thaw, Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda said this week.

BNN summary of the week: Levits urges protecting officials. Riga City Council toppled. Tax changes planned

The BNN gives you a summary of the key events of the past week, told in news stories of the following topics: Serious signals; Perseverance; Dismissal; Tax changes; Media supervisors; Inflation; Slower over the bridge and Belief protectors.

Prime minister orders development of proper government MPC monitoring rules

Latvian Prime Minister Krišjānis Kariņš has ordered Economy Minister Ralfs Nemiro to immediately commence work on a new mandatory procurement component monitoring project and submit it as soon as possible to ensure efficient control over the system, as confirmed by the prime minister’s office.

1 700 medics infected with coronavirus in China; six dead so far

More than 1 700 medics in China are confirmed infected with the new coronavirus. Six of them have already died, as confirmed by healthcare officials.

Number of foreign guests hosted in Latvian places of accommodation up 1.6%

2.85 million foreign and Latvian visitors stayed at Latvian tourist accommodation establishments in 2019, which is 1.6 % more than in 2018. Compared to the previous year, the number of nights spent by visitors increased by 2.6 %, reaching 5.51 million in 2019.

Experts approve Riga Central Station’s Rail Baltica regional train reception solution

A solution has been found to install a four-lane railway section at Riga Central Railway Station to replace the existing two-lane section. This will help secure not only international and airport connectivity for Rail Baltica trains but also further improve intercity and suburban train services, as reported by the project’s representatives.

Beness Aijo asks Vladimir Putin for political asylum; claims Russia has released him

Beness Aijo, who fled Latvia to avoid criminal prosecution for calls of a violent overthrowing of the government, has asked Russian President Vladimir Putin to provide him political asylum. He also claims Russian authorities have released him from custody.

Share prices plummet on stock markets over concerns for coronavirus

On Thursday, 13 February, share prices around the world plummeted as concerns over the Covid-19 coronavirus epidemic in China. London Stock Exchange index declined shortly after British Finance Minister Sajid Javid’s sudden resignation.

Saeima to add considerable amendments to Criminal Procedure Law

On Thursday, 13 February, Latvian Saeima approved amendments to the Criminal Procedure Law that provide the duty to provide truth in testimony if a person uses the right to testify.

Week’s end in Latvia will be snowy, rainy and windy

Strong wind, which may reach a speed of 25 m/sec along the coast, is expected at this week’s end in Latvia. Air temperature, however, will remain mostly unchanged, as reported by Latvian State Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

National Alliance and New Unity may run in Riga City Council elections separately

Following the decision made by the New Conservative Party to run in upcoming Riga City Council snap elections separately, a similar decision will likely be made by the National Alliance «All for Latvia – For Fatherland and Freedom/LNNK» and New Unity.

Airbnb and Vilnius sign «historic» agreement, taxmen to zero in on short-term rentals

Long chastised for little regulation, Airbnb, a popular short-term rentals platform, was praised this week in Lithuania after capital city Vilnius and Airbnb inked an agreement, envisioning that from February 1 onwards Airbnb will automatically collect Vilnius city tourism tax due per night and per person and transfer the sum directly to the City of Vilnius on behalf of hosts.

Latvian parliament dissolves Riga City Council

The Saeima has decided to dissolve Riga City Council. The city council remains active, however, because the law on its dismissal will come to force the next day after its promulgation. Now President Egils Levits has ten days to make his decision on the promulgation.

Tallinn residents reject proposal to limit driving speed to 40 km/h

Residents of Tallinn have rejected mayor Mihhail Kõlvart’s proposal to limit driving speed within city limits to 40 km/h, forcing the municipality to look for other ways to control road traffic speed, as reported by Estonian public media ERR.

Journalists Kalderauska and Eglītis approved as members of National Electronic Mass Media Council

On Thursday, 13 February, Latvia’s Saeima approved journalists Ieva Kalderauska and Jānis Eglītis as new members of the National Electronic Mass Media Council.

European Parliament urges putting an end to illegal pet trade

To protect animal welfare, pet owners and public health, the European Parliament urges the European Union to come up with an action plan to put an end to illegal pet trade, BNN was informed by EP press-secretary in Latvia Jānis Krastiņš.

Kariņš: Baltic and Nordic region should become Europe’s leader

«Baltic and Nordic countries region will be a leader in Europe when it comes to climate policy, innovations and hybrid-security matters. It is in our interest to enhance this commitment by implementing a reasonable and ambitious policy in these sectors,» said Latvian Prime Minister Krišjānis Kariņš during his meeting with Finnish Prime Minister Sanna Marin.

Animal rights activists show footage of cruel treatment of animals at Lithuanian fur farm

Animal rights activists have made a video recording depicting unacceptable conditions in which minks are kept in some fur mark in Lithuania, as reported by Lithuanian public media LRT with reference to Daily Mail.

Latvian government proposes increasing state family benefits

In the context of expected tax changes it is proposed to increase the family state benefit for children, estimating that this may cost an additional amount from EUR 81 to EUR 97 million a year, according to information available to LETA in regards to the offer for tax policy guidelines for 2021 to 2025.

Lawyers: Olainfarm talks should be analysed by law enforcement institutions

Analysis of recorded Olainfarm talks should be entrusted to law enforcement institutions, and all lawyers should distance themselves from people like Mārtiņš Krieķis. «This would be fair,» said board member of United Multidisciplinary Trade Union, lawyer Alvis Pīlāgs and chairman of Latvian Lawyers Association Rihards Bunka about Krieķis as «person without ethics» in an interview to BNN.

Latvia to request Russia to hand over detained National-Bolshevik Beness Aijo

Latvian office of the prosecutor will ask Russia to hand over the recently detained National Bolshevik Beness Aijo, who had fled Latvia several years ago to join Moscow-supported militants in Eastern Ukraine.

Non-taxable minimum and PIT rates proposed to be changed in context of tax changes

In the context of upcoming tax changes in Latvia it is proposed to change the differentiated non-taxable minimum and PIT, as stated in tax policy guideline changes for 2021 to 2025 available to LETA.

Fox News misinterprets facts by calling Lithuanian cities «the deadliest», LRT says

Although Lithuania stands out among other EU member states with its negative statistics with murders, it is wrong to call Lithuanian cities «the deadliest», as reported by Lithuanian public media fact-checking project LRT Facts, which has called the news reported by American media a «Manipulative/sensationalist headline».

SPRK: level of dissatisfaction with electronic communication services up in Latvia

Compared to 2018, the level of dissatisfaction with service contracts among Latvian consumers had increased 20% last year, whereas complaints over the quality of services had increased 9%, according to information compiled by the Public Utilities Commission on complaints received about electronic communication services.

Saeima opposition will not put obstacles for snap elections in Riga

The opposition of Latvia’s Saeima will not turn to President Egils Levits in relation to the legislative draft detailing dismissal of Riga City Council. This means members of the opposition will not put obstacles in the way for snap elections in Riga City Council.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!