Latviski English По-русски
Ceturtdiena 19.09.2019 | Name days: Verners, Muntis

Beneficial owner status in a company does not always involve receiving material benefits

(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

If a person is declared as a company’s beneficial owner, it does not always mean it is a person who is at the end of the chain and receives material benefits from companies.

Because it is a common assumption among members of society that the moment a person is registered in the Enterprise Register as an beneficial owner, this means he or she owns everything, BNN has decided to dive into requirements of Latvia’s legislation in regards to registration of actual beneficiaries and explain what this status actually means and how this term is misunderstood by society.

In Latvia there is no separation between beneficial owner and a person who has actual control over a legal entity and manager.

The Law on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorism and Proliferation Financing state that a beneficial owner is

a natural person who is the owner of the customer – legal person – or who controls the customer, or on whose behalf, for whose benefit or in whose interests business relationship is being established or an individual transaction is being executed, and it is at least:

regarding legal persons – a natural person who owns, in the form of direct or indirect shareholding, more than 25 per cent of the capital shares or voting stock of the legal person or who directly or indirectly controls it.

This law is based on European Union’s developed directive on declaration of beneficial owners. It is based on this legal framework that every country develops a law to govern registration and identification of beneficial owners in every country.

The confusion with requirements for declaration of beneficial owners lies in the fact that in Latvia a beneficial owner is someone often considered the direct or indirect owner of more than 25% of shares in a company, or a person who does not own anything but still exacts control over the company.

For example, in a situation when a single person has the rights to receive more than 25% of material benefits from a company and another person has the rights to use another shareholder’s voting rights in a company without receiving material benefits and still managing a company this way – both these persons in the eyes of Latvian law are considered beneficial owners. This is true even though one gains benefits thanks to being a shareholder, whereas the other does by controlling a company’s activities even though he or she is not a shareholder in it.

This is why, considering the line for registration as a beneficial owner is having more than 25% of shares in a company, the following situation is entirely possible: a company has four members – one owns 40% and the other three own 20% each. The three of them vote as they like, but their share amount, although considerable, does not exceed 25%. This is why they are not registered as beneficial owners. At the same time, the one who owns 40% may as well be in the minority when compared to other shareholders put together, because the shareholder’s 40% are not enough on their own to secure interests, and yet in the eyes of the law only this shareholder is registered as a beneficial owner.

Meanwhile, looking at the definition of a beneficial owner in Netherlands it becomes clear just how wide the definition is and how it should be interpreted. Dutch laws have two different definitions:

beneficial owner and pseudo beneficial owner.

This means this country has it set that it is primarily necessary to declare beneficial owners in the company they own shares in. If it is not possible to determine beneficial owners or there aren’t any, it is usually considered there are so-called pseudo beneficial owners, often the management of a company, but it is immediately clear that these pseudo persons are revealed to society as people who control the company, not ones who have a major interest in the company (shares).

Pseudo beneficial owners are managers, company boards involved in some company’s operations. These are employees with influence and control over some structure, but they do not have any participation interests. The structure is formed in such a way that a person has de jure control and, at the same time, the person does not receive material benefits.

Such structures are used in cases when a company owner passes a company to someone else as inheritance. To prevent heirs from «running everything into the ground», the initial owner hands the company to a professional management structure. Heirs remain inheritors of material benefits but do not have any control over the company. They are unable to make important managing decisions: dissolve the company’s board, make decisions that could potentially ruin the company, etc. Respectively the structure is formed in a way that a person retains material benefit reception rights but does not have control over the company. Such a structure is outlined in legislation in Netherlands. This means it is primarily important to declare economic beneficial owners. If a company has such owners it is not necessary to declare managers.

There would be less confusion in Latvia if the country’s laws also had a clear distinction between beneficial owners and pseudo beneficial owners, calling the first actual recipients of material benefits and the others – actual controllers or pseudo recipients of material benefits.

Theory in practice

To illustrate the theory detailed above, BNN decided to look into one of the most debated topics in relation to beneficial owners. There are many unclear aspects as to why Swiss lawyer Rudolf Meroni is declared in Latvia’s Enterprise Register as beneficial owner in companies in which Aivars Lembergs owns shares, which is why it is worth studying how the law functions in this specific case.

Lembergs’ rights as beneficial owner are currently under arrest. He is not able to give any instructions to Meroni, who is the holder of arrested property, as to what he should and should not do with the company. Under normal conditions Lembergs would have the rights to attempt to influence the holding’s structure, but he is not allowed to under the current circumstances.

As for the holder of arrested property Rudolf Meroni, for example in Ventbuners’s declaration submitted to the Enterprises Register it is stated that he is neither directly or indirectly a shareholder in Ventbinkers. However, he exacts control over the majority of Ventbunkers shareholder structure. This means in the eyes of Latvia’s law he meets the definition of a beneficial owner. He can be considered a beneficial owner based on the holding’s structure, its corporate posts and decisions made in relation to the arrest. Respectively, Meroni can be considered a beneficial owner of Ventbunkers, Kālija parks, Ventspils Commercial Port because he is in charge of these companies even though he is neither a direct or indirect shareholder.

Any beneficial owner status in a company does not automatically mean status of a co-owner in a company. In the eyes of Latvia’s law, a beneficial owner can be someone who is not the owner of a company but is only in control of it.

Leave a reply

Sigulda municipality turns to police over infection cases in kindergartens

Sigulda municipality has turned to State Police to investigate the link between last week’s uncovered intestinal infection cases, including four infection cases involving salmonella bacteria, as confirmed by the municipality.

Latvian Saeima supports tighter mutual cooperation with USA in rights protection

On Thursday, 19 September, Saeima supported in the second and final reading a legislative draft, approving the September 2004 agreement for tighter cooperation between the Republic of Latvia and the United States of America for protection of rights.

Candidate: FCMC team should learn to work substantially, not formally

The team of Latvia’s Finance and Capital Market Commission should learn to work substantially, not formally, said the candidate for the post of chief of FCMC and Citadele Bank board member Santa Purgaile at a press –conference on Thursday, 19 September.

Lithuanian analysts on Russia-Belarus unification plan: actions louder than words

The announcement by Belarus and Russia this week of their entering into an economic confederacy by 2022 did not go unnoticed in Vilnius, which is courting the idea of recharging its dusty relations with Minsk. Is it just the Slavic countries’ new attempt to fulfil the endeavour?

Russia holds traditional holy man, who sought to drive out Putin

A Siberian shaman, who was on his way to Moscow, to «banish» Russian President Vladimir Putin, has been detained, Russian police has stated.

Costs for delivery of printed press to be compensated in Latvia

On Thursday, 19 September, Latvia’s Saeima supported in the second and final reading amendments to the Postal Law, which provide delivery of printed press under subscription in 2020 under the same rules and conditions that are in force now.

Saeima says state of emergency in Riga’s waste management sector is justified

Latvia’s Saeima has approved the decision made by the Cabinet of Ministers on declaring a state of emergency in Riga’s waste management sector.

Lithuanian PM’s lymhoma treatment met with solidarity by Health Minister

Lithuanian Health Minister has shaved his head expressing solidarity with Prime Minister Saulius Skvernelis, who is being treated against cancer.

Finance and Capital Market Commission applies a considerable fine on PrivatBank

Latvia’s Finance and Capital Market Commission has applied a fine of EUR 1.019 million on AS PrivatBank for violation of the Law on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorism and Proliferation Financing, as confirmed by FCMC Communication Office.

Estonia to pay tens of thousands to municipalities for military training grounds

300 000 euros – such is the sum the Estonian Defence Ministry has undertaken to pay every year to nine municipalities in the territory of which training grounds of the Estonian Defence forces are located.

Competition Council: Riga City Council takes no responsibility for its own mess

«It is unfortunate that Riga City Council has involved others in resolving its own negligent problems without taking any responsibility. Competition Council has issued multiple warnings to make Riga City Council to prepare and prevent the very situation we are in now,» says Competition Council chairperson Skaidrīte Ābrama in regards to the state of emergency declared in Riga.

In Fukushima negligence case, company executives acquitted

A court in Japan has acquitted in a case of alleged negligence as to the 2011 Fukushima nuclear disaster three executives of a power company.

Millions intended for National Acoustic Concert Hall to be spent for other needs

The EUR 23 million allocated by European structure funds for the construction of the National Acoustic Concert Hall, and which were planned to be used for the reinforcement of AB Dam, have been divided for other needs, said Latvia’s Culture Minister Nauris Puntulis.

Finland: 12 days left to UK to submit Brexit amendments

Anti Rinne, the Prime Minister of the presiding country of the European Union, has warned the United Kingdom that it has 12 days to submit proposals to amend the existing withdrawal agreement.

Latvian minister promises to control municipalities’ loans more strictly

The loans taken by municipal companies from the State Chancellery for construction of different infrastructure projects will be evaluated and controlled more carefully, promised Latvia’s Environment Protection and Regional Development Minister Juris Pūce at a press-conference on Wednesday, 18 September.

Police to investigate intestinal infection cases in Sigulda’s kindergartens

On Tuesday, 17 September, Latvia’s State Police commenced a criminal process over the intestinal infection cases observed at kindergartens in Sigulda.

New MEPs express support to EU stance on Brexit in resolution

The new composition of the European Parliament has passed a resolution pledging to reject any withdrawal agreement of the United Kingdom without a backstop and readiness to support a withdrawal extension if the UK requests it.

Estonia wants quicker tobacco price hike and small brewery expansion

Estonian Finance Ministry has tabled proposals to increase excise tax on tobacco products and to allow small breweries to expand, while keeping tax deductions.

State Audit bashes Latvian municipalities for irresponsible loans and massive projects

The practice when many Latvian municipalities borrow money from the state budget to finance excessive and unnecessary construction projects demonstrates short-term thinking and irresponsible attitude towards their future costs, as concluded by State Audit.

Estonian tech firms agree to become climate neutral by 2030

33 Estonian computer technology firms have sealed a Green Pledge at Tallinn Digital Summit, promising to change their operations to a completely environmentally sustainable basis by 2030.

Latvian government allocates considerable finances for ministries’ priorities

The government has decided to allocate an additional amount of EUR 173.0 million from the 2020 budget to finance priorities of ministries and independent institutions.

Lithuanian farmers ditch milk farming due to low milk price

In Lithuania, milk purchase prices are so low that small and medium-sized farms have found it unfeasible to operate and 12% of all milk farms have seized to exist over the past year, LRT reports.

Latvian prime minister urges audit of catering services at education institutions

Following the news about intestinal infection cases in Sigulda and the violations uncovered by the Food and Veterinary Service at nearly all education institutions there, an inspection will be proposed to check the quality of catering services at other education institutions, said Prime Minister Krišjānis Kariņš.

Whistleblower Snowden’s new book targeted by U.S. lawsuit

American whistleblower Edward Snowden has released a new book and on the day of its publication the U.S. government has filed a lawsuit against the book to «recover all proceeds» from its sales.

Latvian government greenlights continuation of territorial reform

In spite of objections from many municipalities, Latvia’s government decided on Tuesday, 17 September, to support Environment Protection and Regional Development Ministry to reduce the number of existing municipalities from 119 to 36.