bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Saturday 17.08.2019 | Name days: Oļegs, Vineta
LatviaLatvia

Court enforces 1 000 euros from Ušakovs for Riga City Council deputy

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

Vilnis Ķirsis (L) and Nils Ušakovs (R)

Riga City Vidzeme Suburb Court has declined suspended Mayor of Riga Nils Ušakovs plea against Riga City Council deputy Vilnis Ķirsis over supposedly offensive statements the latter made against the plaintiff.

According to the court ruling available to LETA, the plea was declined and proceedings in Ušakovs’ plea to find statements made by Ķirsis as offensive and untrue have ended. On top of that, the court has enforced from Ušakovs EUR 1 000 in favour of Ķirsis to cover litigation costs.

The court of justice also noted that the audio recording from a city council meeting shows that Ķirsis said the following: «And if someone asks what the face of corruption is like, they I can say we see two faces of corruption at every meeting of Riga City Council. […]». The court concluded that the statement «face of corruption», considering the content of the sentence and grammatical structure, is nothing more than a reference to a question made by a Riga resident, not a statement that contains the opinion of the plaintiff. As for the part of the statement applied to Ušakovs – Riga City Council’s face of corruption – contains claims not about the plaintiff’s allowed corruption activities, but the corruption in the city council, where the creative expression «face of corruption» is applied to Ušakovs as the head of the municipality.

The court of justice detailed in the ruling that, considering how over a long period of time there has been multiple public accounts regarding suspicions of corruption involving Riga City Council or officials of its capital association and criminal processes were initiated following said suspicions, Ķirsis’ statement regarding corruption in the city council cannot be considered one without justified base.

The ruling also explains that Ķirsis provided the court with excerpts from several minutes of Riga City Council meetings that allow for the conclusion that during meetings chaired by Ušakovs «a certain freedom of speech and expressions was allowed, as part of which participants were allowed to not only criticize opponents but also make offensive statements towards each other». Respectively the court believes this particular detail cannot be ignored in the context of Ķirsis’ statement, because established practice in the general discussion culture also influences the way every participating deputy voices his or her opinions.

The court concluded in the ruling that Ušakovs as chairman of Riga City Council and board chairman of Harmony political party is subjected to the highest level of permitted criticism.

«Additionally the plaintiff as the head of Latvia’s largest municipality needs to understand and accept that assessment of the municipal council’s work (both positive and negative), criticisms and accusations of different kind both from individuals and society as a whole can be associated with and directed at the plaintiff as the head of the municipality,» the ruling explains.

The court also referenced the practice of the European Court of Human Rights. This court noted in its 2007 ruling in the case Diena et Ozoliņš c Lettonie that even statements that offend politicians and state officials is the price one has to pay for political competition and freedom of public discussions, which serve as guarantees for democratic society.

The ruling is subject to appeal within 20 days.

The dispute is associated with events that took place during Riga City Council’s meeting of 31 October 2018. During this meeting, Ķirsis commented on the situation with connection of heating services in Riga.

In his speech, Ķirsis announced that the situation is considered an example for how much Riga’s residents suffer from the corruption caused by Harmony’s policy. «More than 20 000 Riga residents experienced autumn not only outside but also inside their homes when the heating season began. This happened because of corruption of one particular party. And if someone asks what the face of corruption is like, they I can say we see two faces of corruption at every meeting of Riga City Council. While they are enjoying nice tans on board a yacht in Monaco, Riga’s residents are forced to freeze. Every time they receive news about freezing residents they add another ice cube to their cocktails and continue enjoying life,» said Ķirsis.


Leave a reply

Week in Lithuania: PM Skvernelis undergoes surgery, Nausėda meets Merkel, rebukes Latvia

Last week, President Gitanas Nausėda rejected the government’s candidate for EU judge, hints of big changes at Šiaulių Bankas ahead

Independent Deputies Faction joins forces with Honour to Serve Riga

Riga City Council’s Independent Deputies Faction has signed a cooperation agreement with Honour to Serve Riga political party, pledging support for the party’s mayoral candidate Oļegs Burovs, as LETA was told by the faction’s leader Valērijs Petrovs on Monday, 18 August.

Saeima’s MPC investigation committee requests information on every issued license

The parliamentary committee formed to investigate the mandatory procurement component has requested access to information regarding every issued MPC license and decision made by officials in regards to this field, says the committee’s representative Ilze Vanaga.

Latvian athlete receives two-year disqualification

Former Latvian long jumper Ineta Radeviča has received a two-year disqualification, as confirmed by International Association of Athletics Federation’s Athletics Integrity Unit.

Minister: state budget funds will not be used to compensate PNB Bank’s clients

The Deposit Guarantee Fund is sufficient to pay compensations to affected PNB Bank clients. This means not a cent from Latvia’s state budget will be used, said Latvia’s Finance Minister Jānis Reirs in a telephone conversation with public broadcaster LTV programme Rīta Panorāma on Friday, 16 August.

Estonia to invest 22 million in construction of a new TV house

Estonian government has set aside EUR 22 million for the construction of a new public television building, as reported by Estonian public media ERR.

Another one falls – Latvian FCMC halts PNB Bank’s operations

Operations of PNB Bank [formerly Norvik Banka] have been halted in Latvia, as confirmed by Finance and Capital Market Commission.

Unemployment index in Latvia drops – rate down to 6.4% in Q2

In Q2 2019 Latvian unemployment rate constituted 6.4 %. Compared to the previous quarter, unemployment rate fell by 0.5 percentage points, and compared to the rate recorded a year ago, it dropped by 1.3 percentage points.

64.7% of Latvia’s population reportedly employed in Q2 2019

905.6 thousand people or 64.7 % of Latvia’s population aged 15–74 were employed in Q2 2019.

Lithuanian Conservatives’ tensions: can the party split?

The Conservative Homeland Union - Lithuanian Christian Democrats (TS-LKD) have risen to unseen heights lately – although in the opposition now, in 2016 parliamentary election the party racked up a record support in its 30 years’ history.

Minister: Latvia’s social budget surplus has reached one billion

The surplus of the state social budget has come close of the pre-crisis level – EUR 1 billion, said Latvian Welfare Minister Ramona Petraviča in an interview to LTV programme Rīta panorama on 15 August.

Riga City Council permitted to elect mayor after two-month deadline

In spite of the fact that 21 August will mark two months of Riga City Council working without a mayor, a condition that permits Latvia’s Saeima to dismiss the entire city council, deputies of the municipality will nonetheless have the right to elect a mayor after the deadline, says Environment Protection Minister Juris Pūce’s advisor for legal affairs Valdis Verners.

Lithuanian president unhappy with Latvia’s decision to purchase energy from Belarus

Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda has voiced sadness over Latvia’s decision to purchase electrical energy produced at Astravets nuclear power plant in Belarus not far from the Lithuanian border. He admits, however, that this decision was not unexpected for him.

State Real Estate claims ReRe Būve 1 may be trying to circumvent the law

Construction company Rere Būve 1 publicly voices desire to continue implementing the construction contract. However, the construction company’s submitted work schedule for reconstruction of New Riga Theatre has everything changed – volume of work, terms and budget, Latvian State Real Estate reports.

Lithuanian mountaineer dies climbing French Alps

Lithuanian 38-year-old mountaineer Vytautas Mažeika died in a 50 m fall in the French Alps, Lithuanian public media LRT reports with reference to 15min.lt.

Estonia decides to reform pension system; increase not promised

Helir-Valdor Seeder, leader of Estonian coalition party Isamaa, has confirmed that the government has agreed on his proposed pension reform, as reported by Estonian public media ERR.

Ruling party in Lithuania promises national agreement for education affairs

While more and more small town schools close down in Lithuania, the leader of the ruling party promises a «national agreement» for education affairs, as reported by Lithuanian public media LRT.

Viesturs Zeps’ has yet to convince NCP and Unity to support him as mayoral candidate

Mayoral candidate in Riga Viesturs Zeps still has not convinced New Conservative Party and Unity to support him, according to what he said in an interview to public broadcaster LTV programme Rīta panorama on Thursday, 15 August.

Audit: planning problems impede growth of Latvia’s defensive capabilities

Problems with planning are the main reason why Latvia’s defensive capabilities are developing slowly, as concluded by State Audit.

Minister: increase of doctors’ wages is a priority over all other promises

First it is necessary to increase doctors’ wages. Then it will be possible to tackle all other promises, said Latvian Healthcare Minister Ilze Viņķele during a meeting of the Saeima’s Social and Employment Matters Committee on Wednesday, 14 August.

Is Latvia becoming more hospitable? Tourist upturn observed

A total of 781.1 thousand visitors stayed at Latvian tourist accommodation establishments in Q2 2019, which is 1.1 % more than in Q2 2018.

Village in Russia to be evacuated following nuclear accident

Russian authorities have announced evacuation of Nenoksa village, as it is the closest to the military area where a nuclear accident recently happened. This may mean the situation there is far more dangerous than initially reported, as reported by New York Times.

Lithuania’s president says he sees no reason to meet with Putin

A meeting with Russia’s President Vladimir Putin is unlikely and would be pointless, said Lithuania’s President Gitanas Nausėda in an interview to public media LRT.

Shadow of political dealings over SRS. ZZS people – Knoks, Podiņš, Vaivars

Although the State Revenue Service has never had a truly spotless reputation, there is now a much bigger and darker shadow hovering over the service’s director general Ieva Jaunzeme. Serious concerns have been voiced in regards to possible employment of «chosen people» in important posts, which allows them to either halt or push criminal processes forward in order to make life difficult for their political opponents, pretending to fight the good fight while, in reality, realizing some «political hit».

Prime Minister: 2020 budget will be Latvia’s largest one yet

The next year’s budget will be the largest in the history of Latvia and will exceed EUR 10 billion, said Prime Minister Krišjānis Kariņš in an interview to public broadcaster LTV programme Rīta Panorāma on Wednesday, 14 August.

Newest comments