Latviski English По-русски
Friday 24.01.2020 | Name days: Krišs, Eglons, Ksenija

Exclusive | Prosecutor: For blatant disrespect, court should punish Lembergs with arrest not fine him

(+1 rating, 1 votes)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

Lawyer Irina Kauke (left) and Aivars Lembergs

In the criminal case against the suspended Latvian mayor, Aivars Lembergs, the court has found violations: blatant disrespect for judges and deliberate slowing down of court debates. The court should not apply a fine to a person able to pay it «without blinking an eye», but an arrest for at least a day. This would limit his chances of delaying the criminal proceedings, said Juris Juriss, the prosecutor in the case against Aivars Lembergs, who is charged with serious crimes, in an interview with the BNN.

A Day Behind Bars?

Juriss stresses that the sanctions of punishment provided in the Criminal Procedure Law are not efficient enough. Namely, for people with «thick wallets», there is the advantage of paying a fine, instead of assuming responsibility for blatant disrespect for the court in another way.

Meanwhile, if procedural sanctions would be used more effectively, for example, with the deprivation of liberty – it would help continue the process, because the defendant, most probably, would not like to spend a day behind bars.

«Of course, there should be different grades as to which procedural sanctions apply to a certain type of violations. For example, for a blatant disrespect for a court or for deliberate delaying of a criminal process,» commented the prosecutor.

Lembergs’ «performance» in court can postpone the trial for another six months

Currently, state lawyer Genādijs Ivankins has been appointed to Lembergs, yet the defendant has chosen Aivo Leimanis as his new lawyer in court.

Although Leimanis has represented Lembergs before, the lawyer has stated he needs additional time to read the materials of the case. The lawyer has also emphasised that he is on vacation until September 2 and that September is a very busy month for him.

«The court had printed the schedule of Leimanis and according to it, it turns out almost that he is only free on Saturday and Sunday,» Juris Juriss points out.

Juriss comments on the situation saying:

«Effectively, Lembergs signed an agreement with a lawyer, who is actually unable to come to court. This shows that a deliberate delaying of the trial is taking place».

Meanwhile, Ivankins, the sate-appointed lawyer of Lembergs, has noted that he would need about six months to read the materials of the criminal process, which, according to the prosecutor, means that court hearings would not take place during this time. «Now, it looks like the current expectations could come true and the trial of Lembergs would be postponed for several months, since he, as if, has no defence. That is the reason why the side of state prosecution is raising the alarm.»

Not to permit the situation and not to prolong the proceedings for an even longer time, Juriss believes that the court should be stricter in reviewing the defence of fragmented involvement, or how a lawyer’s order is issued and to ban them at the number of two advocates. This would permit avoiding the deliberate delaying of the criminal proceedings.

«In parallel, it would be necessary to accept a state-appointed lawyer, who would provide the motivation for this situation not to repeat itself,» the prosecutor believes.

Planned System?

«Court delaying currently takes place on the pretext of looking for defence, yet our side observed «seeds» for this scenario some time ago. In the view of state prosecution, one of the defence lawyers went against the meaning of the law, when she began issuing a separate order for every court hearing,» Juriss comments on the situation with Lembergs’ lawyer Irina Kauke.

She has taken part both in the pretrial criminal proceedings and in the trial from its beginning. However, over the past few months, according to Juriss, lawyer Kauke carried out a fictional scenario – deliberately applied for orders, which are, as if, about separate speeches of fragments of debates. Thus, Lembergs was able to justify that Kauke was not his defence lawer to the full extent.

«Our projection came true after lawyer Raimonds Krastiņš declared his resignation due to an illness. It turns out that Lembergs has lost his defence, because Kauke somehow isn’t his full lawyer due to many orders staged to Lembergs. Here, the side of state prosecution sees maliciousness. «The ground» for this was prepared deliberately with the aim of delaying the criminal proceedings on the pretext of searching for defence.»

The implementation of the procedural system (issuing defence orders), to the mind of the prosecutor, cannot be illusory, it has to be substantiated with law and existing necessity, not permitting the delaying of criminal proceedings.

Juriss believes that if in this situation, nothing is radically changed with «the issue of the defence», then the verdict in the Lembergs’ case can be expected in two years from now, at the earliest.

«It is important to understand that we want to make the provision of defence more effective, not to limit it. One has to understand that victims are also provided legal assistance, the victims also have the right to have the criminal proceedings end in a reasonable period of time.»

Latvia should be no place for situation, where lawyers use being busy as excuse

«We are looking with caution at an opinion published by the NRA [newspaper] from the chairman of the Latvian Council of Sworn Advocates, Jānis Rozenbergs, that it would be almost impossible to find a defence lawyer in the Lembergs’ trial. NRA mentions in its article a view expressed by Rozenbergs that in total, in Latvia, in the field of every-day criminal law, there are about 350 defence lawyers employed, including 50 to 70, who serve in trials on a regular basis.»

However, if this situation is so overwhelming as NRA claimed in the interview with Rozenbergs, then the state should look at this issue as a whole and perhaps establish an institute of state defence lawyers, notes Juriss.

According to the prosecutor, with such a large amount of defence lawyers, Latvia should not have a situation with lawyers using busyness as an excuse and that it is impossible to find a lawyer, who could ensure his or her constant presence in court hearings.

To add, Lawyer Rozenbergs is also working in the Lembergs’ trial. He represents businessman Ansis Sormulis.

Leave a reply

Bulgaria accuses three Russian citizens for poisoning of arms producer

Three Russian citizens have been charged by Bulgaria over the attempted murder of an arms producer and another two Bulgarians using a poison. One survivor believes there is a link with the poisoning of the Skripals in the United Kingdom.

Ignoring sanctions, Ventspils City Council approves budget created under Lembergs’ watchful eye

In spite of sanctions imposed by USA, Ventspils City Council approved the city’s budget for 2020, which came to be under absolute influence from Aivars Lembergs, on Thursday, 23 January, BNN was told by opposition deputy Aivis Landmanis.

Estonia eyes one-year prison sentence for first-time drunk drivers

Estonian government ministers have proposed harsher sanctions for drunk driving. Their initiative comes after three people got killed in a crash, where a heavily intoxicated driver was involved.

Latvian residents trust National Armed Forces the most and the Saeima the least

Latvia’s residents trust the country’s National Armed Forces and the president the most and the Saeima the least, according to the survey performed by Latvian National Security Academy’s Security and Strategic Research Centre.

In China, coronavirus claims more lives as transport limitations put in place

The Chinese outbreak of a new strain of coronavirus has reached the death toll of 26 people, meanwhile, authorities are trying to keep it from spreading introducing transport movement limitations in at least 10 cities.

Information about VDD new office building’s construction costs is a state secret

Although some media have mentioned different amounts of money the construction of a new office for the State Security Service at the location of former Marss cycling track may cost, the service reports that this information is considered a state secret.

Kariņš: Latvia is no longer the younger brother – our country’s voice is heard

Latvia is no longer the younger brother on the international arena – our country is heard and its opinion is taken seriously, said Latvian Prime Minister Krišjānis Kariņš at annual foreign policy debates on Thursday, 23 January.

Poland passes law on limiting public actions, statements of judges

The Polish Sejm has passed a draft law that sets forth limiting the say of judges over justice appointments, court reform and politics. The limitations have been widely criticised abroad.

Linkaits: banks once again service Ventspils Freeport terminals

The situation with Ventspils Freeport is gradually becoming more relaxed. On top of that, banks once again service port terminals there, as Latvian Transport Minister Tālis Linkaits affirmed in a conversation with journalists on Thursday, 23 January.

Aivars Lembergs picks ex-prime minister’s freelance advisor Grudulis as his lawyer for debates

The suspended Mayor of Ventspils Aivars Lembergs, who is also accused of committing serious crimes and is under US sanctions, has picked once the prime minister of Latvia Māris Kučinskis’ freelance advisor Māris Grudulis as his lawyer for debates in court, as was announced in court on Thursday, 23 January.

What is Lithuanian President’s main reason to skip Jerusalem Holocaust forum?

Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda has unexpectedly flip-flopped on where and how to commemorate the 75th anniversary of the liberation of Auschwitz-Birkenau death camp in Poland. First, he said he will attend the commemoration in Jerusalem, but then changed his mind to pay homage to the Jewish victims in Auschwitz, in Poland. The reason? Well, there is no clear official reason for that – President’s Office did not provide one.

Audit: Rail Baltica slowed by poor risk management and slow progress with municipalities

Delays and cost increase of Rail Baltica project is heavily affected by no risk management and no strategy, as well as slow progress in cooperation with municipalities and passive alienation of properties, Latvian State Audit concluded in its latest report.

China stops public transport in two cities over coronavirus

In China, a new strain of coronavirus has claimed the lives of 17 people. To keep it form spreading, local authorities have stopped the public transport to and from the cities of Wuhan and Huanggang.

BNN investigation | Rebenoks and Krieķis may have plans to return to Olainfarm board despite ties to serious crimes

Ex-Olainfarm officials Mārtiņš Krieķis and Pāvels Rebenoks, the latter also serving as Latvian Economy Minister Ralfs Nemiro’s advisor, may return to the company’s board to, possibly, continue walking «well-travelled path» paved with non-transparent deals, according to information available to BNN.

In Estonia, forgetting to register child’s name can lead to municipality choosing it

Estonian law obliges parents to register the name of their child in a month’s time after giving birth. In the unlikely case of them being late, the law opens right to a local municipality to choose it.

Change of concept? Viesturs Kairišs becomes Dailes Theatre’s artistic director

Dailes Theatre’s board member Juris Žagars has picked Viesturs Kairišs as the theatre’s new artistic director, as journalists were told by Žagars on Thursday, 23 January.

Lukashenko: Belarus needs to diversify its oil imports, introducing Baltic supplies

As Minsk and Moscow are in talks to solve a dispute over the continuation of oil imports from Russia, Belarusian President Alexander Lukashenko has said that Russian supplies could be cut to 30-40% of Belarus’ total imports.

Minister does not exclude possibility of number of municipalities in Latvia increasing

The Administrative Territorial Reform offers reducing the number of municipalities to 39 in Latvia. Still, it is possible there may be one or two more, said Latvian Environment Protection and Regional Development Minister Juris Pūce in an interview to LTV programme Rīta Panorāma on Thursday, 23 January.

Thirteen people die from influenza in Latvia

Three people died from influenza in Latvia last week, increasing the number of victims to 13 for this year’s flu season, according to monitoring data of acute upper respiratory tract infections published by Disease Prevention and Control Centre.

Lithuania tries to halt haulage firm exodus to Poland with new tax

Lithuania is introducing a new «exit tax» to keep road haulage firms from relocating to other European Union member states. The firms say that other ways of moving business abroad will be used.

Corruption fighters: corruption perception indexes decline in Latvia in 2019

Latvia’s positions had worsened slightly in 2019 in global anti-corruption coalition Transparency International composed Corruption Perception Index.

UK parliament passes draft Brexit law

In London, the draft law on the withdrawal of the United Kingdom from the European Union has been finally passed by the Houses of Parliament after years of inability of British legislators to decide on their preferred way out of the bloc.

Harmony prepared to approve Riga’s 2020 budget after Burovs’ dismissal

Political party Harmony will not approve Riga municipality’s 2020 budget while Oļegs Burovs remains in charge of the city council, as reported by the be faction’s head Maksims Tolstojs.

British landlords support cards showing rights of EU guest workers after Brexit

After Brexit, which is due to start with February, European Union citizens will have to prove their settled status when looking for flats. Private landlords has supported a change in the Brexit law for EU citizens to have physical cards to prove it.

Survey: 86% believe roads should be among state budget priorities in Latvia

A total of 86% Latvian residents believe maintenance and repair work of roads should be among state budget priorities, according to results of a survey by SKDS.

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!