bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Saturday 21.09.2019 | Name days: Matīss, Modris, Mariss
LatviaLatvia

Experts on Latvia’s compensations to Jewish community: Good idea poorly developed

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

The Latvian draft law on paying compensations to the Latvian Jewish community for the real estate confiscated by Nazi and Communist occupation powers embodies a good idea, yet the requested sum and articles of law lack clear substantiation, legal experts commented to BNN.

As set forth by the draft law On the Good Will Compensation to the Latvian Jewish Community for Real Estate Illegally Confiscated during Holocaust and Communist Totalitarian Regime submitted by the party alliance Development/For!, for dividing the envisaged funds a public fund would be established.

A representative of the Latvian Finance Minister would work in the council of the fund and the fund would be regularly checked by state institutions.

The planned 40 million euros would be paid out over a period of ten years, resulting in four million euros per year.

The authors of the draft law suggest that the use of the money would also have to be public, the funds would only available for use in the territory of Latvia and for such objectives as culture, education, sport, science, health care, social integration, as well as for providing material help to people outside Latvia, who have suffered in Holocaust in the territory of Latvia.

In case the fund would not comply with the rules of spending, the Finance Minister would then have the right to request for the funds to be repaid to state budget.

Poorly developed proposal

The associate professor of the Law Faculty of the Riga Stradiņš University, Inga Kudeikina, said in an interview with the BNN that it was fine to discuss the issue of restitution to the Jewish community, yet she doubts the quality of the way the proposal has been developed.

Paying compensations to the Jewish community would be possible, but this should take place on a different basis, the legal expert believes.

«First, let’s pay attention to separating politics from law.

Right now, reading this bill, it looks like it’s very political, to put it mildly. It’s quite far from law and the legal framework,» noted Kudeikina.

She also pointed out that the title of the draft law misleads the society – the real estate was not taken away unlawfully. Ownerless property belongs to the state – such was the legal framework at the time and still is.

In the view of Kudeikina, the title of the bill does not correspond neither to the objective, neither to the idea expressed in it.

Additionally, the law expert highlighted that the authors of the bill have only consulted with the Jewish community, although an in-depth analysis, analysis of the experience of other countries and consultations with historians would be necessary. This would be needed to determine if the state can actually assume this responsibility.

Moreover, it has not been found, who were the people, who owned these properties and whether they have heirs, who might have waived their right to the real estate.

It is also yet to be determined, what is happening with the buildings confiscated in the past from Jewish owners and if one group of the society can be singled out in the context of public buildings. Kudeikina also pointed out that the cadastre values, which have been taken as the basis for the calculation of the sum, are fluctuating.

The draft law has not been prepared properly, evaluated the associate professor, as it is not affecting property in the order specified in other normative enactments. The expert warns that a situation is possible, where both a real estate is returned and compensation is paid.

Kudeikina doubts whether without sufficient research compensation can be paid to a community, which does not represent all Jews globally, who had properties in Latvia.

In this case the state undertakes to compensate moral suffering, by compensation is paid to the people. As an analogy, compensations for the damage done by state and municipality can be viewed, but in such cases there always has to be a subject and an object for which the compensation is paid. The bill submitted to Saeima right now would be a «fairly bad precedent», said Kudeikina.

The associate law professor of the Riga Stradiņš University concluded that the draft law is «unsubstantiated, underdeveloped and underresearched» and it «can do more wrong than right ».

According to her, it is possible to pay compensations to the Jewish community, yet in this case the draft law should be developed, studied and very narrow.

International practice

«I’d say that there’s no legal obstacle for lawmakers not to do it. Also, this is the practice of the world.

This state is actually not guilty; however, if this state has indirectly benefited from genocide, then the state should come with a step against it,» expert of constitutional rights Edgars Pastars commented to BNN on the bill of restitution to the Latvian Jewish community.

He noted that it has been established internationally that the classic denationalisation could not have been applied fully to victims of the Holocaust as the heirs were dead. As the state or private individuals have taken over this property, the result is that they have indirectly benefited from the Holocaust.

Pastars emphasises that one may not grow richer at the expense of international crimes, therefore, the acquired benefit should be compensated. As there are no heirs to the real estate, restitution is done to the community as such.

The expert suggests comparing it to the theft of a car. If a car is stolen from an owner and it is later sold to another person, the new owner has to give the vehicle back to its first owner. The issue is not about, whether Latvia is responsible for the genocide against the Jewish community, the issue is about not benefiting from a crime, explained Pastars.

More transparency on EUR 40 million

The expert of constitutional rights explained to BNN that he would like more transparency over how the sum suggested for compensation been determined. It should be found clearly what has been taken away and how to make up for it.

«From the point of view of law, I would say that it’s a matter of a political decision.

There’s no legal problem in proposing this, but it has to be proposed with research and evidence, not only as a gesture. If it’s a gesture, it must have substantial argumentation, why do we use this money this way,» told Pastars.

In addition, he noted that to prevent a similar case with other groups, who have suffered in a genocide, it should be mentioned in the abstract of the draft law that it’s the Jewish community, which has been recognised internationally as a group of victims after systematic violence targeted against it.

«If would be good for lawyers not to mix their emotional opinions and prejudice with legal arguments, but, unfortunately, they often mix these things. For me, it’s unacceptable that antisemitism is turned into legal arguments,» commented Pastars.

Roots

It has to noted that the draft bill by Development/For! has been written in consultation with the Council of Jewish Communities of Latvia. One of the board members of this organisation is Dmitrijs Krupņikovs. His brother, businessman Grigorijs Krupņikovs was earlier referred to as the «grey eminence» of the now defunct party New Era. Edgars Jaunups, now part of the party For the Development of Latvia – one of the parties in the Development/For! alliance – began his political career in the New Era.

Latvian media have reported that at the time the proposal by Development/For! emerged, on the player shirts of the Latvian basketball club VEF Rīga, there appeared the logo of Rietumu banka bank. Jaunups manages VEF Rīga, but the chairman of the council of Rietumu banka is Arkādijs Suharenko, who is also on the board of the the Council of Jewish Communities of Latvia.


Leave a reply

  1. Justs says:

    For enslaving the Baltic people for 700 years Germany should pay 50 Trillion Euro to the Baltic people as reparations.

Competition Council permits sale of Bauskas Alus shares to CIDO Group

Latvia’s Competition Council has approved the sale of 100% of shares in SIA Bauskas Alus to CIDO Group under no special conditions. The deal is planned to be completed within a couple of months.

Rimšēvičs: banks have five billion in Bank of Latvia; country’s economy could benefit

Currently different commercial banks have roughly EUR 5 billion stored in the Bank of Latvia. This money could be «injected» into the country’s economy, as reported by the Latvian central bank’s governor Ilmārs Rimšēvičs.

EU confident new Russia-Ukraine gas deal coming, Ukraine critical

In long-term gas deal talks between Russia and Ukraine about Russian gas transit through Ukraine held in Brussels, the European Union has seen positive signs a new deal could be reached, while Ukraine has expressed readiness stop transit if needed.

Bank of Latvia downgrades GDP growth outlook to 2.5% for 2019

The Bank of Latvia has downgraded GDP growth outlook from 2.9% to 2.5% in 2019 and from 3.1% to 2.6% in 2020, journalists were told by the Bank of Latvia governor Ilmārs Rimšēvičs on 20 September.

August’s producer price level in industry down 0.1% in Latvia

Compared to July, the level of producer prices in Latvian industry dropped by 0.1 % in August 2019. Prices of products sold on the domestic market grew by 0.2 %, but prices of exported products reduced by 0.3 %.

Baltic Restaurants Latvia breached hygiene standards in Sigulda’s kindergartens

Catering service provider Baltic Restaurants Latvia did not follow personal hygiene standards and committed numerous violations for cleanliness and disinfection activities at kindergartens Ieviņa and Saulīte in Sigulda.

Riga Central Market becomes more accessible for disabled people

After taking into account complaints from residents, Riga Central Market’s Gastronomy Pavilion has been made more accessible for people with motor function disabilities and more convenient for sellers, said Prof. Baiba Rozentāle, chairperson of Riga City Council’s Social Affairs Committee.

Estonia in Atomic Agency’s management to look for small-state solutions

After Estonia’s first election to the Board of Governors of the International Atomic Energy Agency, its priorities in the body have been declared as development of technological solutions suitable for small countries for meeting climate objectives and the safe handling of radioactive waste.

Volume of imported petrol to Latvia down 6.7% in seven months

The volume of imported motor petrol to Latvia has declined 6.7% in the first seven months in 2019 when compared to the same period of 2018. The volume of imported diesel fuel has increased 0.1%.

Estonia criticises plan to link EU migrant relocation with financial penalties

As Italy is calling for the reshaping of the migration policy of the European Union, Estonian Interior Minister has voiced opposition to the plan and vowed not to take part in the first debate of the proposal about the centralised relocation of migrants.

RISEBA rector: when students «disappear» in the labour market and never return

The desire to become independent quickly and start earning money often outcompetes students’ desire to study, BNN was told by rector of Riga International School of Economics and Business Administration Irina Senņikova in a conversation about the unfinished education problem in Latvia.

Ryanair O’Leary’s option to earn EUR 99 million approved by 50.5% shareholders

In Europe’s largest airline Ryanair, shareholders have voted with 50.5% in favour of a new renumeration system for chief executive office Michael O’Leary. In case of very successful operations, it sets forth paying him 99 million euros in five years.

PVD: no more E. coli presence found at kindergartens in Sigulda

Investigation of the cause for E.coli spread in Sigulda has been performed to the maximum extent to prevent more infection cases, said Food and Veterinary Service’s director general Māris Balodis in an interview to Latvijas Radio on Friday, 20 September.

EU-South America trade deal unacceptable to Austria

The draft free trade agreement between the European Union and the largest trade bloc in South America, Mercosur, is set to be blocked by the Austrian government as legislators in Vienna believe it would have endangered rainforests and labour rights.

Weather to remain rainy and windy in Latvia

Cyclone activity will continue dictating weather conditions in Latvia on weekends. This means the sky will become clear only briefly, as reported by Latvian State Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

Sigulda municipality turns to police over infection cases in kindergartens

Sigulda municipality has turned to State Police to investigate the link between last week’s uncovered intestinal infection cases, including four infection cases involving salmonella bacteria, as confirmed by the municipality.

Latvian Saeima supports tighter mutual cooperation with USA in rights protection

On Thursday, 19 September, Saeima supported in the second and final reading a legislative draft, approving the September 2004 agreement for tighter cooperation between the Republic of Latvia and the United States of America for protection of rights.

Candidate: FCMC team should learn to work substantially, not formally

The team of Latvia’s Finance and Capital Market Commission should learn to work substantially, not formally, said the candidate for the post of chief of FCMC and Citadele Bank board member Santa Purgaile at a press –conference on Thursday, 19 September.

Lithuanian analysts on Russia-Belarus unification plan: actions louder than words

The announcement by Belarus and Russia this week of their entering into an economic confederacy by 2022 did not go unnoticed in Vilnius, which is courting the idea of recharging its dusty relations with Minsk. Is it just the Slavic countries’ new attempt to fulfil the endeavour?

Russia holds traditional holy man, who sought to drive out Putin

A Siberian shaman, who was on his way to Moscow, to «banish» Russian President Vladimir Putin, has been detained, Russian police has stated.

Costs for delivery of printed press to be compensated in Latvia

On Thursday, 19 September, Latvia’s Saeima supported in the second and final reading amendments to the Postal Law, which provide delivery of printed press under subscription in 2020 under the same rules and conditions that are in force now.

Saeima says state of emergency in Riga’s waste management sector is justified

Latvia’s Saeima has approved the decision made by the Cabinet of Ministers on declaring a state of emergency in Riga’s waste management sector.

Lithuanian PM’s lymhoma treatment met with solidarity by Health Minister

Lithuanian Health Minister has shaved his head expressing solidarity with Prime Minister Saulius Skvernelis, who is being treated against cancer.

Finance and Capital Market Commission applies a considerable fine on PrivatBank

Latvia’s Finance and Capital Market Commission has applied a fine of EUR 1.019 million on AS PrivatBank for violation of the Law on the Prevention of Money Laundering and Terrorism and Proliferation Financing, as confirmed by FCMC Communication Office.

Estonia to pay tens of thousands to municipalities for military training grounds

300 000 euros – such is the sum the Estonian Defence Ministry has undertaken to pay every year to nine municipalities in the territory of which training grounds of the Estonian Defence forces are located.