bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Monday 22.07.2019 | Name days: Marija, Marika, Marina
LatviaLatvia

Experts on Latvia’s compensations to Jewish community: Good idea poorly developed

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

The Latvian draft law on paying compensations to the Latvian Jewish community for the real estate confiscated by Nazi and Communist occupation powers embodies a good idea, yet the requested sum and articles of law lack clear substantiation, legal experts commented to BNN.

As set forth by the draft law On the Good Will Compensation to the Latvian Jewish Community for Real Estate Illegally Confiscated during Holocaust and Communist Totalitarian Regime submitted by the party alliance Development/For!, for dividing the envisaged funds a public fund would be established.

A representative of the Latvian Finance Minister would work in the council of the fund and the fund would be regularly checked by state institutions.

The planned 40 million euros would be paid out over a period of ten years, resulting in four million euros per year.

The authors of the draft law suggest that the use of the money would also have to be public, the funds would only available for use in the territory of Latvia and for such objectives as culture, education, sport, science, health care, social integration, as well as for providing material help to people outside Latvia, who have suffered in Holocaust in the territory of Latvia.

In case the fund would not comply with the rules of spending, the Finance Minister would then have the right to request for the funds to be repaid to state budget.

Poorly developed proposal

The associate professor of the Law Faculty of the Riga Stradiņš University, Inga Kudeikina, said in an interview with the BNN that it was fine to discuss the issue of restitution to the Jewish community, yet she doubts the quality of the way the proposal has been developed.

Paying compensations to the Jewish community would be possible, but this should take place on a different basis, the legal expert believes.

«First, let’s pay attention to separating politics from law.

Right now, reading this bill, it looks like it’s very political, to put it mildly. It’s quite far from law and the legal framework,» noted Kudeikina.

She also pointed out that the title of the draft law misleads the society – the real estate was not taken away unlawfully. Ownerless property belongs to the state – such was the legal framework at the time and still is.

In the view of Kudeikina, the title of the bill does not correspond neither to the objective, neither to the idea expressed in it.

Additionally, the law expert highlighted that the authors of the bill have only consulted with the Jewish community, although an in-depth analysis, analysis of the experience of other countries and consultations with historians would be necessary. This would be needed to determine if the state can actually assume this responsibility.

Moreover, it has not been found, who were the people, who owned these properties and whether they have heirs, who might have waived their right to the real estate.

It is also yet to be determined, what is happening with the buildings confiscated in the past from Jewish owners and if one group of the society can be singled out in the context of public buildings. Kudeikina also pointed out that the cadastre values, which have been taken as the basis for the calculation of the sum, are fluctuating.

The draft law has not been prepared properly, evaluated the associate professor, as it is not affecting property in the order specified in other normative enactments. The expert warns that a situation is possible, where both a real estate is returned and compensation is paid.

Kudeikina doubts whether without sufficient research compensation can be paid to a community, which does not represent all Jews globally, who had properties in Latvia.

In this case the state undertakes to compensate moral suffering, by compensation is paid to the people. As an analogy, compensations for the damage done by state and municipality can be viewed, but in such cases there always has to be a subject and an object for which the compensation is paid. The bill submitted to Saeima right now would be a «fairly bad precedent», said Kudeikina.

The associate law professor of the Riga Stradiņš University concluded that the draft law is «unsubstantiated, underdeveloped and underresearched» and it «can do more wrong than right ».

According to her, it is possible to pay compensations to the Jewish community, yet in this case the draft law should be developed, studied and very narrow.

International practice

«I’d say that there’s no legal obstacle for lawmakers not to do it. Also, this is the practice of the world.

This state is actually not guilty; however, if this state has indirectly benefited from genocide, then the state should come with a step against it,» expert of constitutional rights Edgars Pastars commented to BNN on the bill of restitution to the Latvian Jewish community.

He noted that it has been established internationally that the classic denationalisation could not have been applied fully to victims of the Holocaust as the heirs were dead. As the state or private individuals have taken over this property, the result is that they have indirectly benefited from the Holocaust.

Pastars emphasises that one may not grow richer at the expense of international crimes, therefore, the acquired benefit should be compensated. As there are no heirs to the real estate, restitution is done to the community as such.

The expert suggests comparing it to the theft of a car. If a car is stolen from an owner and it is later sold to another person, the new owner has to give the vehicle back to its first owner. The issue is not about, whether Latvia is responsible for the genocide against the Jewish community, the issue is about not benefiting from a crime, explained Pastars.

More transparency on EUR 40 million

The expert of constitutional rights explained to BNN that he would like more transparency over how the sum suggested for compensation been determined. It should be found clearly what has been taken away and how to make up for it.

«From the point of view of law, I would say that it’s a matter of a political decision.

There’s no legal problem in proposing this, but it has to be proposed with research and evidence, not only as a gesture. If it’s a gesture, it must have substantial argumentation, why do we use this money this way,» told Pastars.

In addition, he noted that to prevent a similar case with other groups, who have suffered in a genocide, it should be mentioned in the abstract of the draft law that it’s the Jewish community, which has been recognised internationally as a group of victims after systematic violence targeted against it.

«If would be good for lawyers not to mix their emotional opinions and prejudice with legal arguments, but, unfortunately, they often mix these things. For me, it’s unacceptable that antisemitism is turned into legal arguments,» commented Pastars.

Roots

It has to noted that the draft bill by Development/For! has been written in consultation with the Council of Jewish Communities of Latvia. One of the board members of this organisation is Dmitrijs Krupņikovs. His brother, businessman Grigorijs Krupņikovs was earlier referred to as the «grey eminence» of the now defunct party New Era. Edgars Jaunups, now part of the party For the Development of Latvia – one of the parties in the Development/For! alliance – began his political career in the New Era.

Latvian media have reported that at the time the proposal by Development/For! emerged, on the player shirts of the Latvian basketball club VEF Rīga, there appeared the logo of Rietumu banka bank. Jaunups manages VEF Rīga, but the chairman of the council of Rietumu banka is Arkādijs Suharenko, who is also on the board of the the Council of Jewish Communities of Latvia.


Leave a reply

  1. Justs says:

    For enslaving the Baltic people for 700 years Germany should pay 50 Trillion Euro to the Baltic people as reparations.

We have to be patient – Latvian minister about citizen detained in Iran

We have to be patient in the matter concerning Stena Impero tanker’s crew and the Latvian citizen who are detained by Iranian authorities. A lot depends on how political events unravel, says Foreign Affairs Minister Edgars Rinkēvičs.

Committee: potential NEPLP members’ reputation is their promoters’ responsibility

Responsibility for the reputation of potential members of Latvia’s National Electronic Mass Media Council should be taken by organizations that recommend them, said head of 12th Saeima’s Human Rights and Public Affairs Committee Inese Laizāne.

Latvia to test individual budget model to support people with mental disorders

Welfare Ministry and ten municipalities will use EU Social Fund’s co-financing to test a new approach for social service provision to adults suffering from mental disorders. In other countries this approach is known as «individual budget model».

UK in emergency meeting over Iran-seized tanker with Latvia on board

British government members, intelligence and military chefs are holding an emergency meeting over the seizure by Iran of a UK-flagged oil tanker with a Latvian crew member on board in the Persian Gulf.

Latvian lawyer and ex-judge Uldis Bērziņš killed in Mārupe

Lawyer and ex-judge Uldis Bērziņš was killed in Mārupe, Latvia, according to information from LETA.

Audit uncovers a lack of transparency in use of Latvian Agriculture Ministry’s money

Unclear accounting and use of finances, council members with ties to associations assess money allocation for associations, trips to Spain and Italy for no reason, as well as hundreds of projects with no tangible results – State Audit assess use of finances in Agriculture Ministry’s funds.

Estonian President cycles 135 km in amateur Tour de France

Estonian head of state, Kersti Kaljulaid, showed an example of active lifestyle as she cycled 135 kilometres in Étape du Tour de France on Sunday, the amateur stage of the annual bicycle classic.

Latvian minister may consider raising tax on diesel fuel to finance road maintenance

In order to find money to finance road maintenance in Latvia, the option of increasing excise tax for diesel fuel is not entirely excluded, said Latvia’s Transport Minister Tālis Linkaits in an interview to public broadcaster LTV programme Rīta Panorāma on Friday, 22 July.

Court ruling on Estonia ferry disaster seen as big disappointment

The ruling of a French court in a compensation case over the tragic sinking of Estonia ferry in 1994 has been described as a big disappointment by lawyer of the relatives of victims.

Latvian citizen among sailors of British tanker detained by Iran

Among the crew of the British tanker detained by Iran is one Latvian citizen, according to the report from Latvia’s Foreign Affairs Ministry.

Heavy rain expected in Latvia at week’s beginning; air temperature to reach +29° C

The beginning of the week in Latvia will be rainy, as low atmospheric pressure and rain clouds move through Latvia. Nevertheless, at the end of the week air temperature will reach +29 C, as reported by State Environment, Geology and Meteorology.

In Ukrainian parliamentary election, win of Zelenskiy's party coming

Ukraine has held its snap parliamentary election, where, according to exit polls, Servant of the People party lead by Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskiy has won with a clear majority.

Week in Lithuania: CB denies Swedbank’s Syria links, PM Skvernelis to change some ministers

Last week, PM Saulius Skvernelis revealed that the Government mulls taxing property and polluting cars, Lithuanian Railways said it will keep contract with Latvia's Sigmen, Court disqualifies itself from Paleckis case.

BNN summary of the week: Cutting a pie. Minimal wage. Dangerous games

Is there a pleasant aroma of a fresh pie in the air? Judging by events of the past week, the tasty smell of the 2020 budget has already spread across government corridors even though the dough is not ever ready.

Latvia among Baltic States with first quarter’s highest budget deficit

In Q1 2019, the general government budget deficit ratio to GDP in Latvia was higher than the average across the EU, according to data published by Eurostat.

Latvia’s industrial producer price level up 0.4% in June

Compared to May, the level of producer prices in Latvian industry rose by 0.4 % in June 2019. Prices of products sold on the domestic market grew by 1.5 %, but prices of exported products reduced by 0.7 %.

Curious career zigzags. From shipping schemes to a warm seat in Latvian Railway

Shadow of doubt over fraud worth five million euros. Career twists with Lembergs’ approval. Secret peace treaty following Uldis Augulis’ entry to Transport Ministry. Illegal state of monopoly in the industry. What hides behind Latvian Railway chief’s «spotless» reputation?

Estonian TransferWise hires Netflix’s ex-chief financial officer

Estonian-led financial transactions start-up TransferWise has announced expansion of its board of directors with the former chief financial officer of the American online television service Netflix, David Wells.

Ukraine to reform citizenship process following Russian passport move

Volodymyr Zelenskiy, the President of Ukraine, has ordered changes to the process for receving Ukrainian citizenship reacting to a Moscow decree increasing the number of Ukrainians eligible for fast-track Russian passports.

SES: barrels with chemicals found in Baldone are not harmful to people or environment

The barrels found in Baldone containing different chemicals do not present any direct threats to the environment or people, as reported by State Environment Service.

U.S. shoots down Iranian aircraft amid rising tensions in Persian Gulf

With American-Iranian relations being tense, U.S. President Donald Trump stated that an American naval ship had downed an Iranian drone that threatened the ship in the Arabian Sea.

NATO StratCom does not consider FaceApp more dangerous than Facebook

The US Democratic Party is concerned about Russian-made FaceApp, which allows its users to imagine how they might look like when they are old and retired. NATO StratCom, however, does not consider the app to be more dangerous than other apps users entrust their personal data with.

Additional information to be asked for in Latvian prosecutor general’s evaluation

Saeima deputies who initiated the investigation if there are reasons the justify dismissal of Prosecutor General Ēriks Kalnmeiers have been asked to clarify their request by providing more detailed information in relation to conclusions mentioned in their request.

Latvian minister wants more responsibility for the state in children rights protection

The new children’s rights protection model will delegate more functions to the state, said Latvian Welfare Minister Ramona Petraviča.

Scandinavian tourist killers in Morocco convicted to capital punishment

In Morocco, for the murder of two Scandinavian tourists, three Islamic State group supporters have been sentenced to death.