Latviski English По-русски
Monday 24.09.2018 | Name days: Agris, Agrita

Option to abstain from vote proposed to be liquidated to reduce possibility of hiding opinions

(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RUOn Monday 18 September, a citizens’ initiative will be submitted to the Saeima to liquidate the option to abstain from votes in the parliament. representative Annija Emersone notes Saeima deputies were elected to make decisions, not avoid them. The current order in the Saeima allows deputies to not only vote in favour and against decisions, but also abstain from votes entirely.

The co-author of the initiative, Ir journalist Pauls Raudseps emphasizes that this option is wrong and misleading. This is why it is proposed to be liquidated. «It is deputies’ job to represent the nation in the decision-making process – in the development of laws, approval of officials and in other matters. Abstaining means admitting one’s inability to handle duties and misleading voters about any opinions the deputy may have.»

It is stated in the Constitution that the Saeima forms its opinions with the absolute majority of votes from deputies. This means ‘abstaining’ votes are not counted as votes ‘against’. This means there is a possibility of decisions being declined even if the vote was attended by all 100 deputies, of which 50 vote in favour and the other 50 abstain, note representatives.

Authors of the initiative also say that experience shows that deputies often use the option to abstain from important state votes. In 2011, for example, then the Latvian President Valdis Zatlers initiated Saeima vote after members of the parliament did not permit a search in Ainārs Šlesers’ home. The outcome of the vote was as follows: «35 in favour, 7 against and 37 abstained. This means deputies voted in favour five times more often than against. However, the matter was decided by deputies who abstained from the vote. They basically voted against, but hid their decision behind supposed neutrality.»

«Abstaining from the vote could have far-reaching consequences, which can be seen from the Saeima’s decision to save Šlesers from the search,» notes supporter of the initiative, Ir magazine editor in chief Nellija Ločmele. «Materials of the oligarch talks have caught society’s attention. Those talks were the main reason for KNAB to request a search in Šlesers’ home. Perhaps some valuable evidence would have been obtained otherwise. This means the vote of Saeima’s abstaining deputies can be considered a major obstacle for the investigation, the failure of which is currently being evaluated by Saeima’s committee. This is why the option to abstain from votes still affects Latvia’s society six years later.»

In many parliaments of the world, including countries with long-standing democratic traditions, deputies do not have the option to abstain from votes. This applies to parliaments in the UK, USA, Austria, Ireland, Canada, Malta, Netherlands, Slovenia and Australia. Members of parliaments in Denmark and Sweden have the option to abstain, but the final decision is decided only by votes in favour and against.

«Some may object that there are votes in which it would not be ethical to participate. For example, if the matter in question affects their personal interests. But even now deputies can simply not attend such votes. The current option to abstain does not resolve the problem,» says Raudseps. «It does exactly the opposite, because it misleads votes, since abstaining from the vote basically means the same as voting against.»

This is why authors propose crossing out words ‘or abstained’ from the last sentence of the first part of Section 139 of Rules of Procedure of the Saeima – «The Members who have voted “for” or “against” or “abstained” shall be regarded as having participated in the vote». This would mean all decisions made by the Saeima would be decided by the majority of votes either in favour or against.

If deputies are denied the right to abstain from votes, the possibility of them misleading voters and hiding their opinions would be made non-existent. This would increase deputies’ responsibility before their voters, representatives say.


Leave a reply

Week in Lithuania. President proposes amendments to restrict bailiffs' remuneration

Lithuanian President Dalia Grybauskaitė is putting forward amendments aimed at restricting bailiffs' financial remuneration to up to 15 per cent of the amount recovered.

BNN summary of the week: pre-election heat, rule of law in Latvia, Baltics prepare for Pope’s visit

BNN offers a summary of this week’s topical news in a variety of categories: Elections; Change; Stagnation; Fight; Visit; Investigation.

Court reschedules viewing of criminal case due to Non-citizens Congress leader’s poor health

Riga City Vidzeme Suburb Court announced today that the viewing of the criminal case in which leader of Non-citizens Congress Aleksandrs Gapoņenko is accused of inciting national hate will be postponed to a later date.

Producer prices in industry up 1.0% in Latvia in August

Compared to July, level of producer prices in the Latvian industry rose by 1.0 % in August 2018. Level of prices of products sold on the domestic market grew by 1.9 %, but of exported products – went up by 0.1 %.

Bishop: priest suspected of sexual abuse to be operated on in hospital

Pāvels Zeiļa, who is a priest of Rezekne Aglona diocese and the suspect in the criminal case regarding sexual violence and human trafficking, will undergo a complicated surgery on Friday, 21 September, as reported by Bishop Jānis Bulis.

Study: residents withdraw money from ATMs less often but in larger amounts

Every now and then discussions about dropping cash money altogether become active in society, AS PrivatBank representatives say.

HND Grupa design company, involved in Zolitude tragery, declared insolvent

Building engineer Ivars Sergets company HND Grupa, which was involved in the case revolving around the Maxima supermarket that collapsed in Zolitude, killing 54, not five years ago, has been declared insolvent, as reported by Latvijas Avīze.

Deputy Chief of State Fire and Rescue Service suspected of misappropriation

Latvia’s Interior Affairs Ministry’s Internal Security Bureau has detained deputy chief of State Fire and Rescue Service Ints Sēlis and one other official – a senior inspector, as reported by Panorāma programme of LTV.

Washington sanctions China for buying Russian military equipment

U.S. government has introduces sanctions against the Chinese army over a purchase of fighter jets and missile systems from Russia, despite a U.S. sanctions law targeting Moscow for attempts to sway in the 2016 U.S. election.

Autumn expected to begin soon in Latvia

Friday, 21 September, is expected to be warm in Latvia. Sun and considerable amount of clouds are expected, but not precipitation. Wind will draw in from the south, reaching a speed of 15-17 m/sec in western and central regions, as reported by Latvia’s Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

Brexit: a finish line with no end in sight

Less than 200 days are left before Britain officially leaves the European Union. The state of the agreement between Britain and EU only serves to create more chaos, from which neither Britain nor EU, or even Latvia will benefit.

EU underlines to London: No-deal Brexit also option

European Union's top officials and member state leaders planned to push for a Brexit deal in October, while urging London to give ground on the issues trade and the Irish border by November, to avoid a no-deal Brexit.

Lithuanian PM, a presumable presidential hopeful, set to curb grocery price growth

Having chastised food retailers on many occasions for high grocery prices, Saulius Skvernelis, the Lithuanian Prime Minister, stepped forward in the bid to harness local supermarkets. The presumed presidential candidate of the ruling Farmers and Greens (LVŽS) has summoned this week executives of major retail food chains, scolded them and reaffirmed his pledge to rein in the edging up prices.

Industrial prices in Estonia – up by 3.4% on year

The industrial price index in Estonia has risen from August 2017 to August this year by 3.4%, official statistics show.

Latvian parliament approves transition to competence-based approach in education content

On Thursday, 20 September, Latvia’s Saeima approved in the final reading amendments to the Education Law, necessary for the gradual introduction of competence-based approach in education materials.

Latvian Saeima wants to disallow shareholders to work in company management board

On Thursday, 20 September, Saeima approved in the first reading amendments to the Credit Institutions Law that provide for multiple measures to enhance Latvia’s finance system and its long-term stability, as reported by the parliament’s press-service.

Aglone Council prohibits residents from organizing protests during Pope Francis’ visit

A protest against the Catholic Church’s ban on abortions and expression of shock in relation to the recent sex scandals involving Catholic priests was planned to take place in Aglone during Pope Francis’ visit, but the city council decided to disallow them.

Latvian parliament conceptual supports pension bonus indexation

On Thursday, 20 September, Saeima supported in the first reading several initiatives for a more rapid pension climb for several groups of pensioners, as reported by Saeima press-service.

Majority Saeima deputies support open president vote; UGF members fail to decide unanimously

On Thursday, 20 September, amendments to the Constitution regarding open election of the state president were approved in the second reading.

Four Estonian parties have strong support, enough to enter Riigikogu

Four Estonian parties are believed to currently have enough support to enter the Estonian parliament, a broad opinion poll showed, as leading parties compete for voter backing.

Vitol Group concerned over state of rule of law in Latvia; turns to state officials

One of the largest energy resource traders in the world – Vitol Group – has sent a letter to Latvia’s highest ranking officials, expressing deep concern over the rule of law and application of legislative acts in the litigation between LatRosTrans and Polocktransneft Druzba over the EUR 66 million worth technological oil.

As Pope heads to Baltics, more attention to Catholic sex abuse

The time, when Roman Catholic Pope Francis is set to visit the Baltics, greatly differs from the visit by Saint John Paul II in 1993. There is public resentment over the countries spending several million euros to host the trip of the pontiff and the Catholic sex abuse scandals are topic of discussion.

Officials asked to take responsibility for misuse of state resources

If misuse of state resources takes place, officials have to take responsibility and pay for the damages caused to the state, says Public Expenditure and Audit Committee chairman Andris Bērziņš.

May asks EU not to divide Britain, while Brussels waits for UK change of position

At a European Union summit in Austria, UK's Prime Minister Theresa May called on EU leaders leave behind "unacceptable" Brexit demands that according to her may rip Britain apart.

Saeima decides to divide EUR 8.3 million of healthcare budget funds to finance reforms

Saeima’s Budget and Finance Committee has supported the initiative to divide EUR 8.277 million from the planned chronic patient care funding to further finance reforms in the country’s healthcare system.