bnn.lv Latviski   bnn-news.com English   bnn-news.ru По-русски
Wednesday 21.08.2019 | Name days: Linda, Janīna
LithuaniaLithuania

Removal of a controversial memorial plaque in Vilnius triggers a firestorm

FaceBook
Twitter
Draugiem
print
(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RU

Vilnius Mayor Remigijus Šimašius

Linas Jegelevičius for the BNN

What many believe was a controversial decision of Vilnius mayor Remigijus Šimašius, the removal of a memorial plaque early Saturday morning to Jonas Noreika, a high-rank pre-war Lithuanian military officer and an anti-Soviet resistance fighter implicated in Jews’ genocide, in central Vilnius has triggered a major firestorm, with the sides trading insults and accusations.

The plaque was placed on the facade of the Wroblewski Library of the Lithuanian Academy of Sciences.

A tough question

The bottom line question is this: can someone, even such a staunch defender of statehood as Noreika, known to the public more as Generolas Vėtra (General Storm), be glorified with a major smear on the escutcheons – Noreika allegedly approved the Nazi administration’s decisions to establish a Jewish ghetto and seize their property in the north-eastern Lithuania.

Asked by BNN to weigh in on the question being raised by many analysts this week in Lithuania, Kęstutis Girnius, a Lithuanian analyst of American descent, called it «a very difficult question».

«We have a combination of historical and political matters. On one hand, with the record he (Noreika) has he is a legitimate national hero, but, on the other hand, he had a high post on the Nazi administration and was responsible for setting up a ghetto and appropriating Jewish assets. Therefore, some people deem him a Holocaust perpetrator, someone who cannot be honoured in any form, at least not in Lithuanian capital. In the cusp of the controversy is bad timing – why the plaque was removed in the middle of night and why the decision was made exclusively by the mayor himself?» Girnius said.

MP asked Prosecutor General to opine

Conservative party stalwarts, MPs Laurynas Kasčiūnas, Audronius Ažubalis and Gabrielius Landsbergis (the latter is chairman of Lithuania’s Homeland Union- Lithuanian Christian Democrats, known colloquially as the Conservative party) were raging against this week particularly vociferously. The former even asked to the Prosecutor’s General office to probe the mayor’s actions.

«I am ashamed that a true Mankurt (according to a Kyrgyz legend, mankurts were prisoners of war who were turned into slaves by being exposed in the hot sun with their heads wrapped in camel skin – L. J) stands at the helm of my native town, Vilnius. I am ashamed he is unable to separate oppressors and collaborators, who willingly handed freedom of our nation to Communists, from those who, under very complicated conditions, sought to retain our state’s independence and who have always been on the side of our state,» Kasčiūnas lambasted Šimašius on his Facebook account.

Mayor defends decision

Šimašius however defended himself, arguing that the decision to remove the plaque was aimed at applying the “equal principle” to all memorial signs related to totalitarian regimes, be it the removal of the Soviet statues from the Green Bridge four years ago, or the removal of the plaque to Noreika.

He nevertheless admitted that removing the plaque clandestinely in early morning hours was the only mistake he made in passing the decision.

The mayor’s decision was notably applauded by equally many high-ranking politicians and influencers, like the celebrity TV producer Edmundas Jakilaitis.

So who is wrong?

It depends how you look at it

«What I see ongoing now is a major clash of views and perceptions on morality, values and what true human virtues are. It is all about how we look at it. Simply speaking, can someone, albeit very courageous and who himself perished from oppressors (Noreika was murdered by KGB after his apprehension in 1946 – L. J.), be praised after committing a major error in the life?» Arvydas Anušauskas, a Lithuania historians and parliamentarian, asked rhetorically, referring to Noreika’s implication in Holocaust.

Historians, including Anušauskas, do not even question what now has been known for long: as head of Siauliai County during the Nazi occupation period, Noreika signed documents on the establishment of a Jewish ghetto and on arrangements regarding Jewish property.

Bad timing

However, Anušauskas was perplexed that the plaque was removed without broader consultations with historians, besides, nearly in way too early hours.

«It was not up to the mayor to decide what to do with it. His decision to do it singlehandedly is deplorable and certainly lacked consistency,» Anušauskas emphasised to BNN. «I find it weird when the Noreika plaque, according to Šimašius, has nothing to do with totalitarian regimes, however the monument to Petras Cvirka (a controversial Lithuanian writer who in 1940 went along with others went to Moscow to ask the-then dictator Joseph Stalin to allow Lithuania to join the Soviet state – L.J.)    supposedly is (related to them),» noted Anušauskas.

Bad publicity

As a matter of fact, public discussions on this plaque have been simmering in Lithuania for many years.  Lithuania’s Jewish community has been long urging Lithuanian authorities to take down the plaque honoring Noreika. Not without the community’s exertion, several articles blasting Lithuania, and Vilnius, for honoring Noreika, have appeared in influential Western media, including «The New York Times».

«All along, there have been persistent whispers that General Storm, whose real name was Jonas Noreika, also helped the Nazis kill Jews. But these were largely discounted as the work of ill-willed outsiders serving a well-orchestrated campaign by Moscow to tar its foes as fascists,» stated a New York Times journalist in his article last autumn.

Approached by BNN, the Communication Department of Vilnius Municipality, did not say what part the international pressure has played on Šimašius’ decision, but insisted that any piece of unfavourable information harms the city’s interests.

Grant Gochin, a Jewish US citizen of Lithuanian descent, has sued Lithuanian government’s historical institute for what he called is «facilitating» of Noreika «honouring». He’s lost in court several times in recent years but has vowed to take the issue to the European Court of Justice.

Plaque was smashed in spring

The plaque in April was smashed with a hammer by Stanislovas Tomas who unsuccessfully bid for the European Parliament. It was latter glued back together and put back on the wall, however.

The International Commission for the Evaluation of the Crimes of the Nazi and Soviet Occupation Regimes in Lithuania has concluded that, in Noreika’s case, there are «undeniable facts»  about his involvement in the formation of ghettos and seizure of Jewish assets, and they also underlined that nobody denies his merits to Lithuania and independence but these history pages and specific biographic facts of this person do not allow honoring him in public and making him a hero. This is also what Lithuanian Foreign minister Linas Linkevičius underscored defending the Šimašius decision.

Also last week, Vilnius City Council decided to rename a small street in central Vilnius named after Kazys Škirpa, a controversial 20th century Lithuanian diplomat and military officer, due to his declared anti-Semitic views. Both decisions received support and backlash.

Amid the scandals Lithuanian President Gitanas Nausėda has called for «a moratorium on erasing historic memory», insisting that the discussions need to involve more institutions and experts to formulate the principles and regulation of a national memory policy.


Leave a reply

Subsidies to controversial Riga transport company could increase by EUR 20 mln

Amid the criticism of the Riga municipal transport company Rīgas satiksme for its losses and their effect on the Latvian state budget, a plan has been voiced to increase its subsidies, now 120 million euros, by another 20 million euros, Latvian Radio reports.

Latvian Minister keeping adviser detained by corruption watchdog for now

Latvian Agriculture Minister Kaspars Gerhards will clarify the reason, why his advisor and the mayor of the city of Ogre, Egils Helmanis, has been detained by corruption investigators, to decide on keeping him in office.

Trump, Macron willing to readmit Russia to G7, despite Crimea annexation

The leaders of France and the United States have expressed their backing to readmitting Russia to the G7 conference of world powers in 2020, despite Ukraine’s Crimea still being held by Moscow, CNN reports.

Latvian excise tax income up by 8% in first half of 2018

The Latvian excise tax income in the first half of 2019 has been 521 million euros, –an increase by 39 million euros, or 8.1% – compared to the respective period last year, showed data by the Latvian State Revenue Service.

Latvian PM: Most of freely available 2020 budget funds already earmarked

Discussing the 2020 Latvian national budget, Latvian prime minister Krišjānis Kariņš pointed out that its fiscal space is limited by previous decisions and that the expected losses of the Riga transport company will not permit raising wages and pensions nationally.

Corruption watchdog detains Ogre city mayor Helmanis

The Latvian Corruption Prevention and Combating Bureau has on Wednesday detained the mayor of central Latvian city of Ogre, Egils Helmanis, according to LETA news agency.

New members to Freeport of Riga Authority elected, despite criticism

The Riga City Council elected to the Board of the Freeport of Riga Authority, mayor Oļegs Burovs and councilman Sandris Bergmanis, despite heavy criticism of the latter for incompetence and lack of vision.

Italy loses government, coalition of right-wing, anti-establishment parties collapses

Italy has lost its government with Prime Minister Giuseppe Conte announcing resignation after the right-wing League party pushed for no-confidence motion to its own government.

Kaljulaid opposed to Estonian minister after police chief scandal

Alleging that Estonian Interior Minister Mart Helme has violated the law by trying to sack top police chief, Estonian President Kersti Kaljulaid has stated that the minister has no place in the government.

Planned Latvian economic cases’ court conceptually backed by government

The plan by the Latvian Ministry of Justice to establish a court of economic cases has on Tuesday, August 20, been supported by the Latvian Cabinet of Ministers.

Riga deputy mayor posts go to Harmony and independent politician

In the Riga City Council, deputy mayors have been elected with one post going to Anna Vladova from Harmony and the other – to Vadims Baraņņiks from the group of independent councilmen.

Latvia charges energy company executives for attempted fraud

Two board members of Latvian power company SIA Rīgas enerģija have been charged in a criminal case for an attempt to acquire with deceit the rights to supply electricity as part of the mandatory procurement component programme.

Consumer protection: 34% of Latvians admit post-vacation financial difficulties

During vacation, 77% of Latvians spend more money than planned, but 34% admit having trouble making ends meet after vacation, according to a poll by the Latvian Consumer Protection Centre.

Firms like Riga transport company to be banned from working with losses, minister says

As the European Union’s statisticians have classified the Riga municipal transport company Rīgas satiksme in the debt of the national budget, it is planned in Latvia to prohibit such companies from working with losses, Latvian Finance Minister Jānis Reirs has told LNT 900 sekundes programme.

Minor dies in large fire in Latvia

An underage person has been found dead in a large fire in the Latvian region of Vidzeme, the Latvian Fire and Rescue Service has said. Person wascsaved from burning house in Liepāja.

UK aims to end free entry of EU citizens on October 31

UK to stop free migration from European Union member states to the country right after the likely no-deal Brexit on October 31, the British government has stated.

Riga city elects new mayor – Oļegs Burovs – and restores decade-old coalition

The Riga City Council has elected Oļegs Burovs as the new mayor, ending two months of political discussions and restoring the coalition that has ruled in the Latvian capital for ten years.

EU: Rīgas satiksme cuts Latvian budget fiscal room in 2020 by 72 mln EUR

The Riga city company Rīgas satiksme should, according to European Union criteria, be in included in the general government sector, thus it would cut the fiscal space of the 2020 Latvian state budget by 72 million euros, Finance Ministry stated.

Latvijas Krājbanka’s administrator recovered 542 thousand euros in July

The administrator of the insolvent Latvian bank Latvijas Krājbanka recovered 524 444 euros in July, which is by 75% more than a month earlier, according to the official gazette Latvijas Vēstnesis.

Latvian post-reform administrative centres to have 2 000 - 630 000 populations

After the planned administrative reform of Latvia, the population size of the administrative centres of the new municipalities is expected to vary from 2 000 to 632 000 people, according to a conceptual report by the Ministry of Environmental Protection and Regional Development.

A week of warm, but changing weather forecast for Latvia

Weather in Latvia this week is expected to be summer-like and warm, with rain expected on Thursday and Friday, according to the Latvian Environment, Geology and Meteorology Centre.

Kabul wedding terror attack committed by Islamic State, the group says

Responsibility for the terror attack in Afghanistan, where explosives killed 63 people. has been claimed by the Afghan branch of the Islamic State terrorist group.

British Gibraltar releases seized Iran oil tanker

An Iranian oil tanker detained by Gibraltar, part of the United Kingdom, has sailed away from port after being allowed to do so despite Washington’s call to detain it again.

BNN summary of the week: Latvia’s biggest budget; PNB Bank halts operations; Latvia sad with Latvia

Some positive news surfaced in Latvia this week – Prime Minister Krišjānis Kariņš announced that the country’s next budget will be the largest one yet and will exceed EUR 10 billion. In spite of this, however, financial difficulties have been observed – PNB Bank has ended up in a tight spot. The bank’s shortage of funds has forced Finance and Capital Market Commission to halt all of the bank’s financial operations.

Week in Lithuania: PM Skvernelis undergoes surgery, Nausėda meets Merkel, rebukes Latvia

Last week, President Gitanas Nausėda rejected the government’s candidate for EU judge, hints of big changes at Šiaulių Bankas ahead

Newest comments