Latviski English По-русски
Ceturtdiena 21.11.2019 | Name days: Andis, Zeltīte

Saeima’s Legal Affairs Office warns about potentially anti-Constitutional initiative

(No Ratings Yet)

Baltic news, News from Latvia, BNN.LV, BNN-NEWS.COM, BNN-NEWS.RUBefore deciding on Welfare Ministry’s offer to reduce the length of payment period for unemployed benefits and their size, Latvia’s Saeima deputies are urged to check the legislative draft’s compliance with the Constitution, as concluded by Saeima’s Legal Affairs Office.

The Legal Affairs Office stresses that the reduction of the guaranteed social security benefit can be considered a limitation of rights backed by Section 109 of the Constitution of the Republic of Latvia. This is why it is the parliament’s duty to assess the legislative draft’s compliance with the Constitution and make sure the planned rights limitations matches the principle of proportionality.

The legislator has a duty to make sure the selected legislation was not picked arbitrarily and has rational and objective facts behind it, and that the reduction of the payment period length and benefit size is not disproportionate. It is also important to plan out possible alternatives to the regulation, Saeima lawyers suggest.

According to the Legal Affairs office, the legislative draft’s annotation does not provide a clear and unambiguous explanation for the draft’s compliance with Section 109 of the Constitution. This is why deputies are invited to request a more detailed explanation about the chosen regulation’s compliance with the Constitution, and ‘only once full confidence about both the unemployed benefit’s payment length and size reduction’s proportionality has been reaffirmed’, decide on its approval.

«Although the legal arbitrariness principle does not exclude the possibility for the state to amend existing regulation, the state must take into account the rights the preservation or implementation of which may create a legal, justified and comprehensive arbitrariness for residents,» Saeima’s Legal Affairs Office writes.

To protect residents in the event of legal arbitrariness, when a person receives the status of an unemployed person before new regulation has come to force, the legislative draft allows for expanding transition requirements and stating that a person who received unemployed status prior to 31 December 2019, unemployed benefits are to be provided, calculated and paid in accordance with legislative norms that were in force before the aforementioned date.

«Nevertheless, we wish to turn attention to the fact that this condition does not make it sufficiently clear which legislative norms are applicable in the event if a person loses their unemployed status within 12 months and then receives it again,» Saeima’s lawyers write, adding that the Constitutional Court has declared it is the parliament’s duty to make sure legislative norms are formulated in an unambiguous way and allow for correct interpretation. ‘We urge to clarify the proposed transition requirements to protect the rights of people who received unemployed status prior to 31 December 2018 and ones who received it again within 12 months of that,’ the Legal Affairs Office urges.

Welfare Ministry, meanwhile, sees no problems with the proposal’s compliance with the Constitution. Looking at compliance of proposed changes to Section 105 of the Constitution, which states that every person has the right to own property, the ministry says rights to own property include the rights of the state to limit use of property in accordance with public interests, which stems from the property’s social function – each owner has the duty to keep in mind the interests of others.

«A person’s paid state social insurance fees guarantee their right to receive support if they become unemployed. However, payment of the fee does not guarantee a specific amount. As long as the person is not provided support, the person has neither ownership rights for this service nor the right for a future benefit amount,» Welfare Ministry believes.

Looking at the compliance of proposed changes to Section 109 of the Constitution, which states that every person has the rights for social security in the event of retirement, inability to work, unemployment and other such cases, Welfare Ministry says the Constitutional Court has noted that the state has a duty to provide people with support in the even of unemployment and ensure the person is not left with no way to support themselves. Still, the ministry says the specific section of the Constitution does not detail a duty for the state to preserve for the person the same or equal income level they had prior to becoming unemployed.

«Unemployment insurance, like every other form of insurance, is based on a principle of solidarity. At the same time, it contributes to the longevity of the state social insurance special budget,» Welfare Ministry explains its position.

The ministry believes changes have a legitimate goal driving them – ensuring welfare for society, motivating unemployed persons to seek jobs more actively, as well as contributing to the longevity of the social insurance special budget. «Considering the goal – by promoting unemployed persons’ return to the labour market and thereby helping to resolve the labour force availability problem, it is also possible to divert funds to help raise minimal retirement pension calculation base, as well as state social insurance benefit for disabled people, it is believed to be sufficient public benefit, reaching which it is allowed to proportionally limit legal interests of private persons,» Welfare Ministry wrote to deputies.

As it is known, on 30 October the Saeima supported in the first reading amendments to the Law on Insurance in the Event of Unemployment, shortening the unemployed benefit payment period’s length from nine to eight calendar months.

Leave a reply

BATL board member: Latvia should offer Belarusian partners an attractive offer

«To ensure potassium salt from Belarus returns to Latvia, we have to do our homework – make railway infrastructure more efficient, reduce tariffs and give Belarusian partners an attractive offer. And we need to act quickly. The new legislative initiative for the opening of the border railway section for all cargo carriers is a strong signal to help strengthen cooperation between Latvia and Belarus,» stresses Baltic Association – Transport and Logistics board member Ivars Landmanis.

Court sees personal promotion attempts in claims about delays with Maxima tragedy case

Riga City Pardaugava Court denies claims made by a number of people about slow progress with the review of the criminal case regarding the Zolitude tragedy. On top of that, the court says those are attempts to secure positive personal promotion at the expense of the tragedy’s victims and such claims mislead society.

Lithuania courts idea of establishing a state commercial bank

If you were this week to flick through pages of Lithuanian print and online outlets, the topic of banking will pop up on top. Lithuania’s Scandinavian capital-based commercial banks SEB and Swedbank are closing their regional branches, cash operations are gone in most bank affiliates, there are fewer ATM machines around, mortgage interest rates in Lithuania are higher than elsewhere and I can go on with the list on local banks’ sins. How to rein in the situation in banking sector?

Google, Facebook business incompatible with privacy rights, says Amnesty International

Human rights organisation Amnesty International has found in a study that the «surveillance-based business model» of Facebook and Google's is incompatible with the right to privacy. The U.S. companies disagree.

Latvia’s efforts to achieve climate neutrality may require billions of euros

Latvia has not yet estimated the costs of moving towards climate neutrality, but they may reach billions of euros, said Environment Protection and Regional Development Ministry’s deputy state secretary Alda Ozola at the Energy and Climate Plan 2030 – Road towards Sustainable Country forum on Thursday, 21 November.

Ex-president: 13th Saeima is not responsible for previous parliament’s «cuckoo eggs»

Latvia’s ex-president Vaira Vīķe-Freiberga believes there is no reason to dissolve the 13th Saeima.If the previous Saeima left some «cuckoo eggs» for the new parliament before leaving, such as something in legislation, this does not mean the current Saeima is to blame, says the ex-president.

If Riga City Council fails to resolve waste management problem, Pūce may initiate dismissal

If Riga City Council fails to resolve the waste management problem by 11 December, Environment Protection and Regional Development Ministry will likely initiate the city council’s dismissal, said Environment Minister Juris Pūce in a conversation with journalists on 21 November.

Rats in Estonia cut e-governance services

In Estonia, which sees itself as the world’s first digital nation, has experienced an interruption of state e-services, caused, apparently, by rats in Harju County around Tallinn.

Saeima deputies: bio-economy is a major strategic development direction for Latvia

Bio-economy is one of the main strategic directions for Latvia and the National Development Plan for 2021-2027 needs to have a section dedicated to bio-economy. It needs to detail a specific vision for necessary innovations, labour force resource and capital attraction.

Greece to close overcrowded migrant camps

The Greek government has announced plans to shut down overcrowded open migrant camps to open closed and smaller centres.

Cērps: financial stability should be the main priority for the Bank of Latvia

One major priority for the Bank of Latvia should be responsibility over the stability of the financial system, said potential candidate for the post of the Bank of Latvia and ex-chairman of the Finance and Capital Market Commission Uldis Cērps.

Spanish court points to Ryanair baggage fee excessiveness

Europe’s leading airline Ryanair has been fined by a court in Spain that ruled that asking a fee for hand baggage is excessive.

European Commission positive about Latvia’s budget for 2020

Latvia maintained budget discipline in its next year’s budget plan, the deficit is within acceptable borders, but the tax portion’s decline before the economy generally does not allow for rapid increase of public expenditures, including wages, pensions and benefits, the European Commission admits.

Terrorist attack victim numbers decline, but many countries remain at risk of terrorism

The number of people who died in terrorist attacks around the world had dropped 15.2% in 2018. Nevertheless, the number of countries that are under risk of terrorist attacks has only increased since then, as reported by the Institute for Economics and Peace on Tuesday, 20 November.

Swedish TV: U.S. investigates Swedbank over violations of Russia sanctions

With U.S. and European Union’s sanctions banned from cooperating with Russian weapon maker Kalashnikov, Swedbank has been involved in sending large sums between the shareholders of the Russian firm and the owner of Kalashnikov USA, Swedish television SVT reports.

Saeima’s committee views residents’ request on postponing increase of party funding

On Wednesday, 20 November, Saeima’s Mandates, Ethics and Submissions Committee conceptually supported the legislative draft on the initiative signed by more than 11 000 residents in regards to the significant increase of funding for political parties and its submission to the parliament’s Budget Committee for review.

Estonia sees no alternative to NATO and says it’s strong

Estonia’s top diplomate Urmas Reinsalu has announced prior to a meeting with counterparts from other NATO nations that he considers the alliance strong and sees no alternatives to it.

Supplying all Latvian residents with food would cost nearly EUR 12 million per day

In the event of a threat to the state, supplying Latvian residents with food would cost the state budget approximately EUR 12 million per day, according to estimates from Agriculture Ministry, which were performed in line with adoption of a comprehensive state security system.

State Revenue Service employees’ «glances» at sensitive files and symbolic penalties

Employees of Latvia’s State Revenue Service have been punished multiple times for leaking sensitive data in the past. People received insignificant disciplinary penalties while the leaked information may have ended up in the hands of less than honest people. Why is it that state security matters protected as well as empty hockey gates and who should be held responsible?

Malta arrests businessman in journalist murder case

Maltese authorities have arrested in the murder case of journalist Daphne Caruana Galizia on Wednesday a well-known entrepreneur Yorgen Fenech. Police and Fenech himself have not yet commented publicly on the operation

Latvia’s finance minister bets on tax reform to find money for healthcare

To find necessary funding for healthcare, Latvia’s Finance Minister Jānis Reirs proposes creating «a fair system» in the context of the expected tax reform in which all employed taxpayers will be able to participate.

Levits: Principle of irresponsibility is entrenched in Latvia

Latvian President Egils Levits, discussing the issue of doctor wages in the country, has said: «We have developed for a long time a mechanism of irresponsibility». The head of state gave an interview to Latvijas Televīzija’s programme Rīta Panorāma on Wednesday, November 20.

Riga Mayor ready to resign, if no new majority in City Council

Riga Mayor Oļegs Burovs is looking for a new majority after cooperation with his party has been stopped by Harmony party. If no new majority is established, Burovs would resign, he said in an interview with Latvijas Radio.

Lithuanian firefighters protest over low pay and outdated equipment

Lithuanian firefighters have reminded of government commitments in the field in a protest in Vilnius over the average wage of 430 euros and outdated equipment.

Sweden discontinues investigation into Wikileaks Assange over rape

Swedish investigators have decided to end investigation into Julian Assange, the whistle-blower organisation Wikileaks, over alleged rape that has been upheld since 2010.

Newest comments

Do NOT follow this link or you will be banned from the site!